Department of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, The University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA 52242, USA.
Ann Biomed Eng. 2013 Jul;41(7):1505-15. doi: 10.1007/s10439-013-0751-4. Epub 2013 Feb 8.
Predicting pressure induced wall stress in intracranial aneurysms continues to be of interest for aneurysm safety assessment. In quasi-static analysis, there are two distinct approaches that one may take, the forward approach and the inverse approach. The inverse approach starts from a deformed configuration and thus is naturally suited to image-based, patient-specific analysis. Early studies by the authors' team suggested that the inverse approach, in the context of estimating the wall stress in cerebral aneurysms, depends weakly on the material description. In this article, we present a population study to further demonstrate the inverse method, in particular, the remarkable feature of insensitivity to material properties. Twenty-six aneurysm models derived from patient-specific images were employed in the study. Wall stresses were predicted in both the inverse and forward approaches using three material models. Results showed that, while forward computation yielded up to ~100% stress difference between some materials, the inverse solutions stayed close across materials. The inverse method, in addition to being methodologically accurate in dealing with pre-deformations, has the added convenience of insensitivity to uncertainties in wall tissue properties. New insight into the stress-geometry relation was also discussed.
预测颅内动脉瘤的压力诱导壁应力仍然是动脉瘤安全性评估的研究热点。在准静态分析中,有两种截然不同的方法,即正向法和逆向法。逆向法从变形构型开始,因此非常适合基于图像的、针对患者的分析。作者团队的早期研究表明,在估计脑动脉瘤壁应力的背景下,逆向法对材料描述的依赖性较弱。在本文中,我们进行了一项群体研究,以进一步证明逆向方法的显著特点,即对材料特性不敏感。研究中使用了 26 个源自患者特定图像的动脉瘤模型。使用三种材料模型在逆向和正向方法中预测壁应力。结果表明,虽然正向计算在某些材料之间产生了高达 100%的应力差异,但逆向解在不同材料之间保持接近。除了在处理预变形方面具有方法学上的准确性之外,逆向法还具有对壁组织特性不确定性不敏感的额外便利。还讨论了对应力-几何关系的新认识。