Lazaratou H
Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Unit, Community Mental Health Center of Byrona-Kesariani, Α' Psychiatric Department, Medical School, University of Athens.
Psychiatriki. 2012 Oct-Dec;23(4):304-13.
Attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is considered one of the most common neurodevelopmental disorders of childhood, characterized by inattention and/or hyperactivity-impulsivity. Even though a strict definition of this entity is constantly sought, ADHD is an often redefined and reconceptualized syndrome. Epidemiological studies show large differences in the incidence, pointing out that the effort of actual taxonomic systems to offer objective diagnostic criteria have not yielded substantial results. Bipolar Disorder (BD) with onset in childhood is distinguished from the adult form by the scarcity of affective symptoms. Very often, neither depressive mood, nor hypomanic euphoria are in the front line being covered by irritability with crises of violence. Children or adolescents have consecutive cycles, which include brief episodes of depressive, hypomanic, manic or mixed periods without free intervals. There was a delay in the recognition of this clinical picture. Τhe diagnostic criteria in the actual taxonomic systems are not separated from those of adults and according to some studies the disorder is under diagnosed mainly in European countries. The contemporary literature deals largely with the relationship ADHD - BD in young people because the two disorders share the same clinical picture with slight variations. Τhe differential diagnosis in favor of BD is mainly based on the presence of affective disorders in the family. The main questions raised are whether there is comorbidity, whether ADHD is overdiagnosed against BD or whether ADHD represents a prodromal manifestation of early onset BD. Children with comorbid ADHD and BD tend to express mostly a stimulant phenotype with a chronic course and have higher rates of antisocial conduct disorder. This particular phenotype suggests a symptomatic continuum between ADHD and early onset BD which is possibly responsible for the difficulties met in differential diagnosis and differences in the rates of comorbidity. It seems that the earlier the onset of BD more often it is combined with symptoms of ADHD which often precede mood disorders. The relationship between BD and ADHD is not just a nosological problem but has important implications for treatment. The confusion regarding diagnostic evaluation and the relationship of these two clinical entities is reflected in the proposed course of therapy particularly with regard tο pharmacotherapy. Τhe elevated rates of comorbidity between ADHD and BD observed in the USA, but not in other countries, are possibly due to the frequent use of stimulants.The dilemmas that arise for the diagnosis of ADHD, BD and their relationship refer to the difficulty of defining the limits of normal and abnormal in the mental health of children and adolescents and of the construction of a taxonomic system that respects the particularities of this developmental age spectrum. To achieve this goal, the search for objectivity in diagnostic criteria is not sufficient but one must also keep in mind psychodynamic factors that put children at the heart of their personal history.
注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)被认为是儿童期最常见的神经发育障碍之一,其特征为注意力不集中和/或多动冲动。尽管一直在寻求对这一病症的严格定义,但ADHD是一种经常被重新定义和重新概念化的综合征。流行病学研究表明发病率存在很大差异,指出实际分类系统为提供客观诊断标准所做的努力并未产生实质性成果。儿童期起病的双相情感障碍(BD)与成人形式的区别在于情感症状较少。很多时候,既没有抑郁情绪,也没有轻躁狂欣快感,取而代之的是伴有暴力发作的易怒情绪。儿童或青少年会经历连续的周期,包括抑郁、轻躁狂、躁狂或混合期的短暂发作,且没有无发作的间歇期。对这种临床症状的认识存在延迟。实际分类系统中的诊断标准与成人的标准没有区分开来,并且根据一些研究,该病症在欧洲国家主要是诊断不足。当代文献主要探讨了青少年中ADHD与BD的关系,因为这两种疾病有着相似的临床表现,只是略有差异。支持BD的鉴别诊断主要基于家族中情感障碍的存在。引发的主要问题是是否存在共病,ADHD相对于BD是否被过度诊断,或者ADHD是否代表早发性BD的前驱表现。患有ADHD和BD共病的儿童往往大多表现出具有慢性病程的兴奋剂型症状,并且反社会行为障碍的发生率更高。这种特殊的症状表现表明ADHD和早发性BD之间存在症状连续体,这可能是导致鉴别诊断困难和共病率差异的原因。似乎BD起病越早,就越常与ADHD症状同时出现,而ADHD症状往往先于情绪障碍出现。BD与ADHD之间的关系不仅是一个疾病分类学问题,对治疗也有重要影响。关于诊断评估以及这两种临床病症关系的困惑反映在建议的治疗过程中,尤其是在药物治疗方面。在美国观察到的ADHD与BD之间较高的共病率,而在其他国家并非如此,这可能是由于兴奋剂的频繁使用。ADHD、BD的诊断及其关系所引发的困境涉及到界定儿童和青少年心理健康中正常与异常界限的困难,以及构建一个尊重这一发育年龄范围特殊性的分类系统的困难。为实现这一目标,仅在诊断标准中寻求客观性是不够的,还必须考虑将儿童置于其个人经历核心的心理动力学因素。