School of Life Sciences, University of KwaZulu-Natal, Post Bag X01, Scottsville, Pietermaritzburg, 3209, South Africa.
J Chem Ecol. 2013 Mar;39(3):438-46. doi: 10.1007/s10886-013-0259-2. Epub 2013 Feb 19.
Evolutionary shifts in pollination systems within a plant genus are commonly associated with changes in floral scent, reflecting selection mediated through the sensory systems of various pollinators. The most common cetoniine beetle pollinator of grassland Protea species in South Africa, Atrichelaphinis tigrina, previously has been shown to have a strong preference for the fruity floral scent of these plants over the weak scent of their bird-pollinated congeners. However, it is not known which of the many compounds found in the scent of beetle pollinated Protea species play a role for pollinator attraction. Electroantennograms (EAG) from A. tigrina beetles were recorded in response to 15 compounds emitted by Protea flower heads. EAG responses to all 15 compounds were significantly greater than those to the paraffin solvent in which they were diluted. The greatest responses were observed for aromatics (anisole, methyl benzoate, methyl salicylate, benzaldehyde) followed by the monoterpene β-linalool, which can comprise up to 66 % of fruity Protea scents. Five compounds that elicited EAG responses (benzaldehyde, β-linalool, (E/Z)-linalool oxide (furanoid), methyl benzoate, and methyl salicylate) were tested in commercially available yellow bucket traps in the field to test their attractiveness to beetles. Traps baited with methyl benzoate, β-linalool, (E/Z)-linalool oxide (furanoid), and methyl salicylate caught significantly more insects than did those containing paraffin only. Methyl benzoate also was more specifically attractive to A. tigrina than was (E/Z)-linalool oxide (furanoid) and paraffin baited controls. A second field experiment using a combination of linalool vs. paraffin baited yellow or green traps showed that trap color had a significant effect on the number of trapped beetles. Yellow traps yielded a ten-fold higher number of insect catches than did green traps. However, the combination of yellow color and the scent compound linalool yielded the highest number of catches. This study has shown that the cetoniine beetle A. tigrina can detect a variety of floral compounds and is attracted to compounds comprising a large proportion of the blend that makes up fruity Protea scents, adding support for the hypothesis that change in scent chemistry during the shift from bird to cetoniine beetle pollination in this genus were mediated by beetle sensory preferences.
植物属内传粉系统的进化转变通常与花香的变化有关,反映了通过各种传粉者的感觉系统进行的选择。南非草原类 Protea 物种最常见的 Cetoniine 甲虫传粉者 Atrichelaphinis tigrina 以前表现出对这些植物果香花香的强烈偏好,而对其鸟类传粉同属植物的微弱香气则不感兴趣。然而,目前尚不清楚在甲虫传粉的 Protea 物种的花香中发现的许多化合物中的哪一种对传粉者具有吸引力。从 A. tigrina 甲虫记录的触角电图(EAG)对 Protea 花头释放的 15 种化合物作出反应。EAG 对所有 15 种化合物的反应明显大于对其稀释的石蜡溶剂的反应。最大的反应是对芳烃(苯甲醚、苯甲酸甲酯、水杨酸甲酯、苯甲醛),其次是单萜 β-芳樟醇,它可以占果香 Protea 气味的 66%。EAG 反应引起的 5 种化合物(苯甲醛、β-芳樟醇、(E/Z)-芳樟醇氧化物(呋喃型)、苯甲酸甲酯和水杨酸甲酯)在野外的市售黄色桶状诱捕器中进行了测试,以测试它们对甲虫的吸引力。用苯甲酸甲酯、β-芳樟醇、(E/Z)-芳樟醇氧化物(呋喃型)和水杨酸甲酯诱捕的诱捕器捕获的昆虫明显多于仅含石蜡的诱捕器。与(E/Z)-芳樟醇氧化物(呋喃型)和石蜡诱饵对照物相比,苯甲酸甲酯对 A. tigrina 的吸引力也更强。使用芳樟醇与石蜡诱饵的黄色或绿色诱捕器的第二个野外实验表明,诱捕器颜色对诱捕到的甲虫数量有显著影响。黄色诱捕器的昆虫捕获量是绿色诱捕器的十倍。然而,黄色颜色和气味化合物芳樟醇的组合产生了最高的捕获量。这项研究表明, Cetoniine 甲虫 A. tigrina 可以检测到各种花香化合物,并被构成果香 Protea 气味的大部分混合物的化合物所吸引,这为在该属中从鸟类到 Cetoniine 甲虫传粉的转变过程中气味化学变化是由甲虫的感觉偏好介导的假说提供了支持。