Goya T, Tsuchiya R
Dept. of Surgery, National Cancer Center Hospital.
Gan To Kagaku Ryoho. 1990 Apr;17(4 Pt 2):771-6.
Pulmonary resection for metastatic disease in 341 patients resulted in a cumulative survival rate of 36.6% at 5 years and 26.6% at 10 years with an operative mortality of 0.9%. 5-year survival rate was 44.3% in colorectal carcinoma (n = 85), 36.2% in cervical cancer of uterus (n = 35), 40.6% in renal cell carcinoma (n = 32), 50.3% in breast cancer (n = 23), 50.0% in testicular cancer (n = 16), 17.9% in osteosarcoma (n = 33), 34.1% in soft part sarcoma (n = 38). The patients with resected metastatic pulmonary lesions from colorectal and renal cancer showed a good 5-year survival, and then the survival decreased gradually. On the other hand, the survival for testicular and breast cancer, osteosarcoma and soft part sarcoma decreased rapidly in the first 2 to 3 years, but a plateau was reached. Each primary malignancy should be analyzed individually because of the differences of their biologic behaviors. Significant factors influencing survival were (1) patients selection for pulmonary resection, (2) the biologic growth rate of each primary malignancies, and (3) effectiveness of chemotherapy for primary malignancies. Presumably, a good 5-year survival rate after thoracotomy would be a reflection of a length bias, caused by the biologic behavior of the metastatic pulmonary disease. The true benefit for the surgical approaches to metastatic neoplasm of the lung are still controversial.
对341例转移性疾病患者进行肺切除术后,5年累积生存率为36.6%,10年为26.6%,手术死亡率为0.9%。结直肠癌(n = 85)患者的5年生存率为44.3%,子宫颈癌(n = 35)为36.2%,肾细胞癌(n = 32)为40.6%,乳腺癌(n = 23)为50.3%,睾丸癌(n = 16)为50.0%,骨肉瘤(n = 33)为17.9%,软组织肉瘤(n = 38)为34.1%。结直肠癌和肾癌切除转移性肺病灶的患者5年生存率良好,随后生存率逐渐下降。另一方面,睾丸癌、乳腺癌、骨肉瘤和软组织肉瘤的生存率在最初2至3年内迅速下降,但随后趋于平稳。由于每种原发性恶性肿瘤的生物学行为不同,应分别对其进行分析。影响生存的重要因素包括:(1)肺切除的患者选择;(2)每种原发性恶性肿瘤的生物学生长速度;(3)原发性恶性肿瘤化疗的有效性。推测开胸术后良好的5年生存率可能反映了转移性肺部疾病生物学行为导致的长度偏倚。手术治疗肺转移性肿瘤的真正益处仍存在争议。