1 Department of Chemical Engineering, Queen's University , Kingston, Ontario, Canada .
Tissue Eng Part C Methods. 2013 Nov;19(11):829-38. doi: 10.1089/ten.TEC.2012.0693. Epub 2013 Mar 29.
Extracting high-quality RNA from hydrogels containing polysaccharide components is challenging, as traditional RNA isolation techniques designed for cells and tissues can have limited yields and purity due to physiochemical interactions between the nucleic acids and the biomaterials. In this study, a comparative analysis of several different RNA isolation methods was performed on human adipose-derived stem cells photo-encapsulated within methacrylated glycol chitosan hydrogels. The results demonstrated that RNA isolation methods with cetyl trimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) buffer followed by purification with an RNeasy® mini kit resulted in low yields of RNA, except when the samples were preminced directly within the buffer. In addition, genomic DNA contamination during reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) analysis was observed in the hydrogels processed with the CTAB-based methods. Isolation methods using TRIzol® in combination with one of a Qiaex® gel extraction kit, an RNeasy® mini kit, or an extended solvent purification method extracted RNA suitable for gene amplification, with no evidence of genomic contamination. The latter two methods yielded the best results in terms of yield and amplification efficiency. Predigestion of the scaffolds with lysozyme was investigated as a possible means of enhancing RNA extraction from the polysaccharide gels, with no improvements observed in terms of the purity, yield, or amplification efficiency. Overall, this work highlights the application of a TRIzol®+extended solvent purification method for optimizing RNA extraction that can be applied to obtain reliable and accurate gene expression data in studies investigating cells seeded in chitosan-based scaffolds.
从含有多糖成分的水凝胶中提取高质量的 RNA 是具有挑战性的,因为传统的针对细胞和组织设计的 RNA 分离技术由于核酸与生物材料之间的物理化学相互作用,其产率和纯度可能有限。在这项研究中,对几种不同的 RNA 分离方法进行了比较分析,这些方法用于 photo-encapsulated 在甲基丙烯酰化乙二醇壳聚糖水凝胶内的人脂肪源性干细胞。结果表明,使用溴化十六烷基三甲铵 (CTAB) 缓冲液的 RNA 分离方法,然后用 RNeasy® mini 试剂盒进行纯化,除了将样品直接预切碎在缓冲液中之外,结果导致 RNA 的产率较低。此外,在用基于 CTAB 的方法处理的水凝胶中观察到逆转录聚合酶链反应 (RT-PCR) 分析过程中的基因组 DNA 污染。使用 TRIzol®与 Qiaex®凝胶提取试剂盒、RNeasy® mini 试剂盒或扩展溶剂纯化方法之一结合的分离方法提取了适合基因扩增的 RNA,没有基因组污染的证据。就产量和扩增效率而言,后两种方法的效果最佳。研究了溶菌酶对支架的预消化作为增强多糖凝胶中 RNA 提取的一种可能方法,但在纯度、产量或扩增效率方面没有观察到任何改善。总的来说,这项工作强调了使用 TRIzol®+扩展溶剂纯化方法优化 RNA 提取的应用,可用于获得在研究中植入壳聚糖支架的细胞中进行可靠和准确的基因表达数据。