Department of Mechanical Engineering, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA 16802, USA.
J Neural Eng. 2013 Apr;10(2):026016. doi: 10.1088/1741-2560/10/2/026016. Epub 2013 Feb 28.
To explore the use of classical feedback control methods to achieve an improved deep brain stimulation (DBS) algorithm for application to Parkinson's disease (PD).
A computational model of PD dynamics was employed to develop model-based rational feedback controller design. The restoration of thalamocortical relay capabilities to patients suffering from PD is formulated as a feedback control problem with the DBS waveform serving as the control input. Two high-level control strategies are tested: one that is driven by an online estimate of thalamic reliability, and another that acts to eliminate substantial decreases in the inhibition from the globus pallidus interna (GPi) to the thalamus. Control laws inspired by traditional proportional-integral-derivative (PID) methodology are prescribed for each strategy and simulated on this computational model of the basal ganglia network.
For control based upon thalamic reliability, a strategy of frequency proportional control with proportional bias delivered the optimal control achieved for a given energy expenditure. In comparison, control based upon synaptic inhibitory output from the GPi performed very well in comparison with those of reliability-based control, with considerable further reduction in energy expenditure relative to that of open-loop DBS. The best controller performance was amplitude proportional with derivative control and integral bias, which is full PID control. We demonstrated how optimizing the three components of PID control is feasible in this setting, although the complexity of these optimization functions argues for adaptive methods in implementation.
Our findings point to the potential value of model-based rational design of feedback controllers for Parkinson's disease.
探索使用经典反馈控制方法来改进深部脑刺激(DBS)算法,以应用于帕金森病(PD)。
采用 PD 动力学的计算模型来开发基于模型的合理反馈控制器设计。将恢复患有 PD 的患者的丘脑皮质中继能力制定为一个反馈控制问题,其中 DBS 波形作为控制输入。测试了两种高级控制策略:一种由丘脑可靠性的在线估计驱动,另一种作用是消除从内苍白球(GPi)到丘脑的抑制的大量减少。为每个策略规定了受传统比例积分微分(PID)方法启发的控制律,并在基底神经节网络的这个计算模型上进行了模拟。
对于基于丘脑可靠性的控制,具有比例偏差的频率比例控制策略提供了在给定能量消耗下实现的最佳控制。相比之下,基于来自 GPi 的突触抑制输出的控制与基于可靠性的控制相比表现非常出色,与开环 DBS 相比,能量消耗进一步大大降低。最佳控制器性能为具有导数控制和积分偏差的幅度比例,这是全 PID 控制。我们展示了如何在这种情况下优化 PID 控制的三个组成部分是可行的,尽管这些优化函数的复杂性表明在实施中需要自适应方法。
我们的发现指出了基于模型的反馈控制器对于帕金森病的合理设计的潜在价值。