School of Psychology, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK.
Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2013 Sep;22(9):533-42. doi: 10.1007/s00787-013-0393-y. Epub 2013 Mar 2.
Despite evidence for its efficacy and effectiveness, the use of medication for the treatment of ADHD remains controversial. Little is known about the factors that influence clinicians' decisions to use medication for ADHD. Here, we present initial data on the attitudes of prescribing clinicians from the Influences on Prescribing for ADHD Questionnaire (IPAQ)-a new clinician-completed, 40-item scale. The eight IPAQ subscales cover attitudes towards (1) treatment outcome optimisation, (2) the use of rule based over more informal approaches, (3) side effects, (4) symptoms control as the primary goal of treatment, (5) the influence of external pressure on medication-related decisions, (6) the value of taking the child's views into account, (7) long-term medication use and (8) the value of psychosocial approaches for the treatment of ADHD. Sixty-eight clinicians from Belgium and the UK took part. All subscales had acceptable levels of internal reliability (Chronbach's alpha = 0.62-0.78). Overall, clinicians reported taking a rule-based approach to prescribing with a focus on treatment optimisation, taking the child's view into account and valuing psycho-social approaches. They focused on treating broader patterns of impairment, but were wary of the potential side effects and long-term treatment. Psychiatrists scored high on their focus on symptom control and preference for long-term medication use, while paediatricians reported using more rule-based approaches. We identified four distinctive response profiles: (1) pro-psychosocial; (2) medication focused; (3) unsystematic; and (4) response optimizers. Future larger scale studies are required to replicate these profiles and to explore their relationship with prescribing behaviour and treatment outcomes.
尽管有证据表明其疗效和有效性,但药物治疗 ADHD 的使用仍然存在争议。对于影响临床医生决定使用 ADHD 药物的因素知之甚少。在这里,我们展示了来自 ADHD 处方影响问卷(IPAQ)的处方临床医生态度的初步数据 - 一种新的临床医生完成的,包含 40 个项目的量表。八个 IPAQ 分量表涵盖了对以下方面的态度:(1)治疗结果优化,(2)基于规则的方法而非更非正式的方法,(3)副作用,(4)症状控制作为治疗的主要目标,(5)药物相关决策受外部压力的影响,(6)考虑孩子的意见的价值,(7)长期药物使用和(8)心理社会方法治疗 ADHD 的价值。来自比利时和英国的 68 名临床医生参与了研究。所有分量表的内部可靠性均达到可接受水平(Chronbach's alpha = 0.62-0.78)。总体而言,临床医生报告说他们采用基于规则的方法进行处方,注重治疗优化,考虑孩子的意见并重视心理社会方法。他们专注于治疗更广泛的损伤模式,但对潜在的副作用和长期治疗持谨慎态度。精神科医生在注重症状控制和长期药物使用方面的得分较高,而儿科医生则报告说使用了更多基于规则的方法。我们确定了四种不同的反应特征:(1)亲心理社会;(2)药物关注;(3)无系统;和(4)反应优化器。需要进行更大规模的未来研究来复制这些特征,并探讨它们与处方行为和治疗结果的关系。