Suppr超能文献

[成人注意力缺陷多动障碍中哌甲酯的监督下超说明书用药]

[Supervised off-label prescribing of methylphenidate in adult ADHD].

作者信息

Carton L, Dondaine T, Deheul S, Marquié C, Brigadeau F, Amad A, Devos D, Danel T, Bordet R, Cottencin O, Gautier S, Ménard O

机构信息

Department of pharmacology, CHU de Lille et Inserm U1171 Degenerative and vascular cognitive disorders, University of Lille, 59000 Lille, France; Department of psychiatry and addiction medicine, CHU Lille, 59000 Lille, France.

Department of pharmacology, CHU de Lille et Inserm U1171 Degenerative and vascular cognitive disorders, University of Lille, 59000 Lille, France.

出版信息

Encephale. 2019 Feb;45(1):74-81. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2018.05.008. Epub 2018 Aug 16.

Abstract

OBJECTIVE

Off-label prescription is a common practice in psychiatry, raising health and economic concerns. Collegial consultation could allow a framed prescription of treatments that are not authorized in specific indications. Attention Deficit Hyperactivity in adult populations (ADHD) is a striking example of a pathology where off-label prescription is frequent. First considered to be a childhood disorder, the awareness of this condition in adults is increasing, leading to the development of new clinical practices and treatments. However, the adult ADHD diagnosis and its management are still emerging in France despite a high prevalence. Treatment of adult ADHD relies on methylphenidate prescription, but the initiation of this drug is not authorized in adult populations. Methylphenidate is a central nervous system stimulant that is structurally close to amphetamine and acts as a norepinephrine and dopamine reuptake inhibitor. Due to these pharmacological properties, neuropsychiatric and cardiovascular side-effects could occur. Furthermore, its addictive potential has led France to classify it as a psychoactive drug, dispensed via secured prescription. The first prescription and the one-year follow-up are restricted to neurologists, paediatrics, psychiatrists and sleep disorders specialists at hospital. The objective of this article is to propose a multidisciplinary framework for the off-label prescription of methylphenidate in adult ADHD.

METHODS

The Multidisciplinary Advice Consultation for Exceptional Addiction Treatments (Consultation d'Avis Multidisciplinaire de Traitements d'Exception en Addictologie CAMTEA) was first set up in Lille for the prescription of baclofen in alcohol dependence and was then extended to topiramate in binge eating disorder. This procedure has been adapted to the particularities of ADHD in adult populations, the differential diagnosis (bipolar disorder, depressive disorder, anxious disorder, personality disorder, substance use disorder) and the co-morbidities requiring a full psychiatric and neuropsychological assessment. Moreover, a particular attention has been paid to the monitoring of neuropsychiatric, cardiovascular and misuse risk because of the potential side-effects of methylphenidate.

RESULTS

The proposed prescription framework is structured into several specialized consultations. A first psychiatric evaluation aims to diagnose adult ADHD, using the French version of the Diagnostisch Interview Voor ADHD 2.0 questionnaire (DIVA 2.0), and to assess the quality of life impact with the Weiss Functional Inventory Rating Scale (WIFRS). It also searches for the presence of differential diagnosis or co-morbidities. The second appointment consists of a pharmacological evaluation that aims to search for contraindications and potential drug interaction. A neuropsychological evaluation based on standardized tests (Weschler Adulte Intelligence Scale [WAIS IV], Conner's Continuous Performance Test 3 [CPT] and the Minnesota Multiphasic Personnality Inventory [MMPI]) is also required to evaluate neurocognitive disabilities and personality features. Once the parameters of the different assessments have been collected, the synthesis is presented during a multidisciplinary meeting in order to assess the risk-benefit ratio for each patient. Several specialties are involved in this multidisciplinary meeting: psychiatry, addictology, general medicine, addictovigilance, pharmacovigilance and neuropsychology. One strategy among three possibilities can be decided: (1) contraindication to treatment with methylphenidate, (2) attention deficit disorder that does not require medication management, and (3) indication of treatment with methylphenidate with the choice of the pharmacological form (immediate or prolonged release). A biological check-up and an electrocardiogram are carried out systematically before any treatment. If the decision is made to initiate treatment, it is started at the lowest dosage and followed by a titration phase. A weekly follow-up is carried out during the titration phase in order to assess treatment efficacy and safety. After treatment stabilization, the general practitioner can carry out the renewal, and the patient will be reassessed within the framework of the multidisciplinary consultation every 3 months.

CONCLUSION

When an off-label prescription is being considered, it must comply with the basic rules of good clinical practice, and the benefit/risk ratio should be constantly reassessed. The proposed multidisciplinary framework, adapted to the characteristics of adult ADHD and the pharmacological properties of methylphenidate, appears to be an interesting strategy to meet the requirements of the good clinical practice. The complementary assessments carried out and the collegial framework allow enhancing the patient's follow-up and minimize the drug risk, particularly in the psychiatric, addictive and cardiovascular adverse events. Finally, this framework could also help the monitoring of other off-label treatments for ADHD, such as atomoxetine or guanfacine.

摘要

目的

超说明书用药在精神病学领域很常见,引发了对健康和经济方面的担忧。同行协商可以促成针对特定适应症未获批准的治疗方法进行有条件的处方。成人注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)就是一个超说明书用药频繁的突出病症实例。ADHD最初被认为是一种儿童期疾病,如今成人对这种病症的认知正在增加,这促使了新的临床实践和治疗方法的发展。然而,尽管成人ADHD在法国的患病率很高,但成人ADHD的诊断及其管理仍在不断发展中。成人ADHD的治疗依赖于哌甲酯处方,但该药物在成人中起始用药未获批准。哌甲酯是一种中枢神经系统兴奋剂,其结构与苯丙胺相近,可作为去甲肾上腺素和多巴胺再摄取抑制剂。由于这些药理特性,可能会出现神经精神和心血管方面的副作用。此外,其成瘾潜力致使法国将其归类为精神活性药物,需通过安全处方配药。首次处方及为期一年的随访仅限于医院的神经科医生、儿科医生、精神科医生和睡眠障碍专家。本文的目的是为成人ADHD的哌甲酯超说明书用药提出一个多学科框架。

方法

特殊成瘾治疗多学科咨询(Consultation d'Avis Multidisciplinaire de Traitements d'Exception en Addictologie CAMTEA)最初在里尔设立,用于开具巴氯芬治疗酒精依赖的处方,随后扩展到开具托吡酯治疗暴饮暴食症的处方。该程序已根据成人ADHD的特殊性、鉴别诊断(双相情感障碍、抑郁症、焦虑症、人格障碍、物质使用障碍)以及需要全面精神和神经心理评估的共病情况进行了调整。此外,由于哌甲酯可能产生的副作用,对神经精神、心血管和滥用风险的监测给予了特别关注。

结果

提议的处方框架由几次专门咨询构成。首次精神科评估旨在使用法国版的ADHD诊断访谈问卷2.0(DIVA 2.0)诊断成人ADHD,并使用韦斯功能量表评分量表(WIFRS)评估对生活质量的影响。它还会查找是否存在鉴别诊断或共病情况。第二次预约是进行药理评估,旨在查找禁忌证和潜在的药物相互作用。还需要基于标准化测试(韦氏成人智力量表[WAIS IV]、康纳持续性操作测验3[CPT]和明尼苏达多相人格量表[MMPI])进行神经心理评估,以评估神经认知障碍和人格特征。一旦收集了不同评估的参数,就会在多学科会议上进行综合分析,以评估每位患者的风险效益比。该多学科会议涉及多个专业:精神科医学、成瘾医学、普通医学、药物警戒、药物不良反应监测和神经心理学。可以决定三种可能性中的一种策略:(1)哌甲酯治疗禁忌证;(2)无需药物管理的注意力缺陷障碍;(3)使用哌甲酯治疗的指征以及药物剂型(速释或缓释)选择。在任何治疗前都会系统地进行一次生物学检查和心电图检查。如果决定开始治疗,则从最低剂量开始,随后进入滴定阶段。在滴定阶段每周进行一次随访,以评估治疗效果和安全性。治疗稳定后,全科医生可以进行续方,患者将在多学科咨询框架内每3个月接受一次重新评估。

结论

在考虑超说明书用药时,必须符合良好临床实践的基本规则,并且应不断重新评估效益/风险比。所提议的多学科框架适应成人ADHD的特征和哌甲酯的药理特性,似乎是满足良好临床实践要求的一种有趣策略。所进行的补充评估和同行框架有助于加强对患者的随访,并将药物风险降至最低,特别是在精神、成瘾和心血管不良事件方面。最后,该框架还可以帮助监测ADHD的其他超说明书治疗方法,如托莫西汀或胍法辛。

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验