Tufts University, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, 200 College Avenue, Room 113 Anderson Hall, Medford, Massachusetts 02155, United States.
Chemosphere. 2013 Jul;92(6):639-46. doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2013.01.061. Epub 2013 Mar 9.
In this study, we critically examined the available data related to pharmaceutical (PhAC) sorption in biological treatment processes. Using these data, we developed and assessed single and polyparameter quantitative structural activity models to better understand the role of sorption in PhAC attenuation. In contrast to other studies, our analysis suggests that values of the sorption coefficient (KD) are poorly correlated to single parameter models employing logKOW or the apparent partition coefficient (i.e., KOW corrected to the experimental pH). Results from the development of polyparameter models suggest that the range of functional moieties typically incorporated in PhAC molecules offers a diverse set of interactions between PhAC and sludge surface (e.g., hydrogen bonding, electrostatic interactions, and hydrophobic interactions). Of particular importance is the role of dissociation and resulting charge(s) of a PhAC in solution. Results demonstrate that when developing predictive models it is advantageous to separate PhACs based upon the charge of the dominant species at the experimental pH. Yet, use a single model for PhACs which are negatively charged and uncharged may have practical utility. Performance of the polyparameter models, however, was found to plateau with a pred-R(2) between 0.50 and 0.60, even when six statistically relevant predictors are included. This outcome suggests that effective predictive models for PhAC sorption cannot include solely PhAC descriptors, rather they must incorporate critical properties related to the sorbent (i.e., mixed liquor) surface.
在这项研究中,我们批判性地检查了与生物处理过程中药物(PhAC)吸附相关的现有数据。使用这些数据,我们开发并评估了单参数和多参数定量结构活性模型,以更好地理解吸附在 PhAC 衰减中的作用。与其他研究不同,我们的分析表明,吸附系数(KD)的值与使用 logKOW 或表观分配系数(即校正至实验 pH 值的 KOW)的单参数模型相关性较差。多参数模型开发的结果表明,PhAC 分子中通常包含的官能团范围提供了 PhAC 和污泥表面之间的一系列相互作用(例如,氢键、静电相互作用和疏水相互作用)。特别重要的是 PhAC 在溶液中解离和产生电荷的作用。结果表明,在开发预测模型时,根据实验 pH 值下主导物质的电荷将 PhAC 分开是有利的。然而,对于带负电荷和不带电荷的 PhAC 使用单一模型可能具有实际效用。然而,多参数模型的性能发现随着预-R(2)值在 0.50 到 0.60 之间达到平台,即使包含了六个统计学上相关的预测因子。这一结果表明,对于 PhAC 吸附的有效预测模型不能仅包含 PhAC 描述符,而必须包含与吸附剂(即混合液)表面相关的关键性质。