Department of Prevention and Community Health, The George Washington University School of Public Health and Health Services, 2175 K Street, Suite #701, Washington, DC, 20037, USA.
West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources, Department of Perinatal Services, Charleston, WV, USA.
Matern Child Health J. 2014 Jan;18(1):180-190. doi: 10.1007/s10995-013-1252-7.
This study evaluated the effectiveness of the Smoking Cessation and Reduction in Pregnancy Treatment (SCRIPT) Program selected by the West Virginia-Right From The Start Project for state-wide dissemination. A process evaluation documented the fidelity of SCRIPT delivery by Designated Care Coordinators (DCC), licensed nurses and social workers who provide home-based case management to Medicaid-eligible clients in all 55 counties. We implemented a quasi-experimental, non-randomized, matched Comparison (C) Group design. The SCRIPT Experimental E Group (N = 259) were all clients in 2009-2010 that wanted to quit, provided a screening carbon monoxide (CO), and received a SCRIPT home visit. The (C) Group was derived from all clients in 2006-2007 who had the same CO assessments as E Group clients and reported receiving cessation counseling. We stratified the baseline CO of E Group clients into 10 strata, and randomly selected the same number of (C) Group clients (N = 259) from each matched strata to evaluate the effectiveness of the SCRIPT Program. There were no significant baseline differences in the E and (C) Group. A Process Evaluation documented a significant increase in the fidelity of DCC delivery of SCRIPT Program procedures: from 63 % in 2006 to 74 % in 2010. Significant increases were documented in the E Group cessation rate (+9.3 %) and significant reduction rate (+4.5 %), a ≥50 % reduction from a baseline CO. Perinatal health case management staff can deliver the SCRIPT Program, and Medicaid-supported clients can change smoking behavior, even very late in pregnancy. When multiple biases were analyzed, we concluded the SCRIPT Dissemination Project was the most plausible reason for the significant changes in behavior.
本研究评估了西弗吉尼亚州“从一开始就正确”项目选择的戒烟和减少孕期吸烟治疗(SCRIPT)计划在全州范围内推广的效果。通过过程评估,记录了指定护理协调员(DCC)、持照护士和社会工作者在所有 55 个县为符合医疗补助条件的客户提供家庭为基础的病例管理时,SCRIPT 交付的保真度。我们实施了准实验、非随机、匹配比较(C)组设计。SCRIPT 实验组(E 组)(N=259)都是 2009-2010 年想要戒烟的客户,他们提供了一个筛查一氧化碳(CO),并接受了 SCRIPT 家访。C 组是从 2006-2007 年所有接受过与 E 组客户相同 CO 评估并报告接受过戒烟咨询的客户中得出的。我们将 E 组客户的基线 CO 分层为 10 个区间,然后从每个匹配的区间随机选择相同数量的 C 组客户(N=259)来评估 SCRIPT 计划的有效性。E 组和 C 组在基线时没有显著差异。过程评估记录了 DCC 对 SCRIPT 程序的交付保真度显著提高:从 2006 年的 63%提高到 2010 年的 74%。在 E 组中,戒烟率(+9.3%)和显著减少率(+4.5%)显著增加,从基线 CO 降低了≥50%。围产期健康病例管理工作人员可以提供 SCRIPT 计划,而获得医疗补助支持的客户可以改变吸烟行为,即使在怀孕后期也是如此。当分析多个偏倚时,我们得出结论,SCRIPT 传播项目是行为发生显著变化的最合理原因。