Kozaki S, Yanagawa Y, Ueki M, Sugimoto O, Okazaki T, Saeki M, Nomura H, Kanda T, Iwai E, Miyawaki Y
Dept. of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Osaka Medical College.
Gan To Kagaku Ryoho. 1990 Jun;17(6):1189-93.
We treated 14 patients with cyclophosphamide, adriamycin and cisplatin (CAP), and 16 patients with cyclophosphamide, Pirarubicin and cisplatin (CTP). Hematological changes in the peripheral blood were compared in the two groups to determine whether there was any difference in bone marrow suppression. 1) The lowest leukocyte counts were similar in the two groups. The leukocyte count reached its nadir at 11.6 +/- 2.1 days in the CTP group and at 15.1 +/- 2.8 days in the CAP group, a significant difference (p less than 0.01). 2) The leukocyte count recovered rapidly in the CTP group and was significantly higher (p less than 0.01) at 3 to 4 weeks than in the CAP group, and it returned to the pretreatment level in the CTP group in the fourth week. 3) The platelet count reached its lowest level in the second week in both groups. In the CTP group, it was significantly higher (p less than 0.01) than in the CAP group. 4) Reticulocyte count reached its lowest level in the first week in both groups, and then started increasing. 5) In the CTP group, a course of treatment was 28.0 +/- 2.3 days and it was 29.5 +/- 2.3 days in the CAP group. In 28% of the CPA group, it took 30 days or more for the leukocyte count to return to normal after one course, while none of the CTP group did the leukocyte count remain low for 30 days. These results show that CTP causes more rapid bone marrow suppression (particularly leukocytopenia) than CAP, does but that a recovery is more rapid with CTP. These CTP may be a better form of treatment than CAP.
我们对14例患者采用环磷酰胺、阿霉素和顺铂(CAP方案)进行治疗,对16例患者采用环磷酰胺、吡柔比星和顺铂(CTP方案)进行治疗。比较两组患者外周血的血液学变化,以确定骨髓抑制是否存在差异。1)两组患者的最低白细胞计数相似。CTP组白细胞计数在11.6±2.1天达到最低点,CAP组在15.1±2.8天达到最低点,差异有统计学意义(p<0.01)。2)CTP组白细胞计数恢复迅速,在3至4周时显著高于CAP组(p<0.01),且在第四周CTP组白细胞计数恢复到预处理水平。3)两组患者血小板计数均在第二周达到最低水平。CTP组血小板计数显著高于CAP组(p<0.01)。4)两组患者网织红细胞计数均在第一周达到最低水平,然后开始上升。5)CTP组一个疗程为28.0±2.3天,CAP组为29.5±2.3天。在CAP组中,28%的患者一个疗程后白细胞计数恢复正常需要30天或更长时间,而CTP组无一例白细胞计数持续低于正常水平30天。这些结果表明,CTP方案导致的骨髓抑制(尤其是白细胞减少)比CAP方案更迅速,但CTP方案的恢复也更快。CTP方案可能是比CAP方案更好的治疗方式。