University of Iowa Carver College of Medicine, Iowa City, IA, USA.
Acad Radiol. 2013 Aug;20(8):1048-51. doi: 10.1016/j.acra.2012.12.020. Epub 2013 Mar 16.
Chest radiographs can be demanding, making this an area of focus during most first-year resident chest rotations. This often comes at a cost of cross-sectional imaging, and new residents are often not initially comfortable with reading chest computed tomographic angiograms (CTAs) for pulmonary embolisms (PEs). We created a teaching file of CTAs to improve the detection of PEs.
For initial testing, we used videos of 25 cases, which played for 90 seconds (to allow multiple passes) to residents with and without call experience. The presence and location of PEs and the readers' confidence scores were recorded. After initial testing, first-year residents without call experience were given 20 separate known positive CTA videos to scroll through on their own. The goal of this was to allow for individual review and development of individual search strategies. A second testing was done with all levels of residents with the same initial 25 cases, re-randomized to evaluate for improvement.
Initially, first-year residents without call experience identified an average of 14.7 of 18 examinations positive for PEs (versus 15.8 for more senior residents; P < .04). After reviewing the 20 known positive cases, the first-year residents improved, averaging 16.6 (versus 14.7 earlier; P < .01).
We created a fast, simple way to expose novice residents to CTA examinations and increase their accuracy in identifying PEs. After using a teaching file, the ability to recognize PEs improved significantly, and scores were no longer significantly different from those of residents with call experience.
胸部 X 线摄影的要求较高,因此成为大多数第一年住院医师胸部轮训的重点。这通常会导致对横断面成像的忽视,而且新住院医师通常最初不熟悉阅读用于诊断肺栓塞(PE)的胸部 CT 血管造影(CTA)。我们创建了 CTA 教学文件,以提高对 PE 的检出率。
在初始测试中,我们使用了 25 例病例的视频,这些视频播放 90 秒(允许多次观看),供有和没有值班经验的住院医师观看。记录 PE 的存在和位置以及读者的置信度评分。初始测试后,没有值班经验的第一年住院医师可以自行浏览 20 个单独的已知阳性 CTA 视频。目的是允许个人回顾和制定个人搜索策略。然后,对所有级别的住院医师进行了第二次测试,使用相同的最初 25 个病例重新随机评估以评估是否有改善。
最初,没有值班经验的第一年住院医师平均识别出 18 次胸部 X 线摄影检查中有 14.7 次为 PE 阳性(而有值班经验的住院医师为 15.8 次;P <.04)。在查看了 20 个已知阳性病例后,第一年住院医师的表现有所提高,平均识别出 16.6 次(与之前的 14.7 次相比;P <.01)。
我们创建了一种快速、简单的方法,使新手住院医师接触 CTA 检查,并提高他们识别 PE 的准确性。使用教学文件后,识别 PE 的能力显著提高,且评分不再明显低于有值班经验的住院医师。