School of Transportation Engineering, Tongji University, Shanghai 201804, China.
Accid Anal Prev. 2013 Jul;56:22-31. doi: 10.1016/j.aap.2013.02.026. Epub 2013 Mar 26.
The analysis of road network designs can provide useful information to transportation planners as they seek to improve the safety of road networks. The objectives of this study were to compare and define the effective road network indices and to analyze the relationship between road network structure and traffic safety at the level of the Traffic Analysis Zone (TAZ). One problem in comparing different road networks is establishing criteria that can be used to scale networks in terms of their structures. Based on data from Orange and Hillsborough Counties in Florida, road network structural properties within TAZs were scaled using 3 indices: Closeness Centrality, Betweenness Centrality, and Meshedness Coefficient. The Meshedness Coefficient performed best in capturing the structural features of the road network. Bayesian Conditional Autoregressive (CAR) models were developed to assess the safety of various network configurations as measured by total crashes, crashes on state roads, and crashes on local roads. The models' results showed that crash frequencies on local roads were closely related to factors within the TAZs (e.g., zonal network structure, TAZ population), while crash frequencies on state roads were closely related to the road and traffic features of state roads. For the safety effects of different networks, the Grid type was associated with the highest frequency of crashes, followed by the Mixed type, the Loops & Lollipops type, and the Sparse type. This study shows that it is possible to develop a quantitative scale for structural properties of a road network, and to use that scale to calculate the relationships between network structural properties and safety.
路网设计分析可为交通规划者提供有用的信息,帮助他们提高路网安全性。本研究的目的是比较和定义有效的路网指标,并分析道路交通分析区(TAZ)层面的路网结构与交通安全之间的关系。在比较不同路网时存在的一个问题是建立可用于根据其结构对网络进行缩放的标准。基于来自佛罗里达州奥兰治县和希尔斯伯勒县的数据,使用 3 个指标(接近中心度、中间中心度和网格系数)对 TAZ 内的路网结构属性进行缩放:接近中心度、中间中心度和网格系数。网格系数在捕捉路网结构特征方面表现最佳。开发贝叶斯条件自回归(CAR)模型来评估各种网络配置的安全性,其安全性由总事故、州道事故和当地道路事故来衡量。模型结果表明,当地道路上的事故频率与 TAZ 内的因素(例如,区域网络结构、TAZ 人口)密切相关,而州道上的事故频率与州道的道路和交通特征密切相关。对于不同网络的安全影响,Grid 类型与最高的事故频率相关,其次是 Mixed 类型、Loops & Lollipops 类型和 Sparse 类型。本研究表明,有可能为路网的结构属性开发一个定量的规模,并利用该规模来计算网络结构属性与安全之间的关系。