Malver Lasse Paludan, Brokjaer Anne, Staahl Camilla, Graversen Carina, Andresen Trine, Drewes Asbjørn Mohr
Mech-Sense, Department of Gastroenterology & Hepatology, Aalborg University Hospital, Aalborg, Denmark.
Br J Clin Pharmacol. 2014 Jan;77(1):72-95. doi: 10.1111/bcp.12137.
To assess centrally mediated analgesic mechanisms in clinical trials with pain patients, objective standardized methods such as electroencephalography (EEG) has many advantages. The aim of this review is to provide the reader with an overview of present findings in analgesics assessed with spontaneous EEG and evoked brain potentials (EPs) in humans. Furthermore, EEG methodologies will be discussed with respect to translation from animals to humans and future perspectives in predicting analgesic efficacy. We searched PubMed with MeSH terms 'analgesics', 'electroencephalography' and 'evoked potentials' for relevant articles. Combined with a search in their reference lists 15 articles on spontaneous EEG and 55 papers on EPs were identified. Overall, opioids produced increased activity in the delta band in the spontaneous EEG, but increases in higher frequency bands were also seen. The EP amplitudes decreased in the majority of studies. Anticonvulsants used as analgesics showed inconsistent results. The N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor antagonist ketamine showed an increase in the theta band in spontaneous EEG and decreases in EP amplitudes. Tricyclic antidepressants increased the activity in the delta, theta and beta bands in the spontaneous EEG while EPs were inconsistently affected. Weak analgesics were mainly investigated with EPs and a decrease in amplitudes was generally observed. This review reveals that both spontaneous EEG and EPs are widely used as biomarkers for analgesic drug effects. Methodological differences are common and a more uniform approach will further enhance the value of such biomarkers for drug development and prediction of treatment response in individual patients.
在疼痛患者的临床试验中,为评估中枢介导的镇痛机制,诸如脑电图(EEG)等客观标准化方法具有诸多优势。本综述的目的是向读者概述目前在人类中使用自发脑电图和诱发脑电位(EPs)评估镇痛药的研究结果。此外,还将讨论脑电图方法从动物到人类的转化以及预测镇痛效果的未来前景。我们使用医学主题词“镇痛药”、“脑电图”和“诱发电位”在PubMed上搜索相关文章。结合对其参考文献列表的搜索,共识别出15篇关于自发脑电图的文章和55篇关于诱发电位的论文。总体而言,阿片类药物使自发脑电图中的δ频段活动增加,但也观察到高频段活动增加。在大多数研究中,诱发电位的振幅降低。用作镇痛药的抗惊厥药结果不一致。N-甲基-D-天冬氨酸受体拮抗剂氯胺酮在自发脑电图中使θ频段活动增加,诱发电位振幅降低。三环类抗抑郁药使自发脑电图中的δ、θ和β频段活动增加,而诱发电位受到的影响不一致。弱镇痛药主要通过诱发电位进行研究,通常观察到振幅降低。本综述表明,自发脑电图和诱发电位均被广泛用作镇痛药效果的生物标志物。方法学差异很常见,采用更统一的方法将进一步提高此类生物标志物在药物开发和预测个体患者治疗反应方面的价值。