Degaetano Michela, Lacaze Laurent, Phillips Jeremy C
Department of Earth Sciences, University of Bristol, Queens Road, BS8 1RJ, Bristol, UK.
Eur Phys J E Soft Matter. 2013 Apr;36(4):9850. doi: 10.1140/epje/i2013-13036-9. Epub 2013 Apr 18.
We investigate experimentally the runout resulting from the collapse of a granular column containing two particle species that differ in size only. The experimental configuration is strictly two-dimensional (only one particle per width of the experimental tank) and we explore both the role of the initial arrangement and proportion of the two particle sizes in the column, using high-speed videography, and by determining the centres of mass of the big and small particles in the initial column and the final deposit. The duration of the experiment is sufficiently short that large-scale segregation does not occur, however, we find a clear dependence of runout on both initial mixture arrangement and proportion for all conditions. We investigated this observation through detailed analysis of the flow front motion, and identify a characteristic "stopping" phase when dissipation dominates, and we apply a shallow layer model at the flow front to show how the initial mixture arrangement and proportion influence the effective coefficient of friction during emplacement. We find that a bidispersed mixture can induce a larger friction on emplacement than a monodispersed mixture, and the highest coefficient of friction was found for a well-mixed initial arrangement of particles at the proportion that shows maximum horizontal spreading of the flow. These observations suggest that downwards percolation of fine particles takes place at the front of the collapsing column, and so localised size segregation processes at the flow front can control flow mobility. This effect is likely to be important in controlling the mobility of large geophysical flows that occur on finite time scales, and whose deposits typically show granular segregation at the front and edges but not throughout the entire deposit.
我们通过实验研究了仅在尺寸上不同的两种颗粒组成的颗粒柱坍塌所导致的径流。实验配置严格为二维(实验槽的每个宽度仅一个颗粒),我们使用高速摄像技术,并通过确定初始柱体和最终沉积物中大小颗粒的质心,探究了柱体中两种颗粒尺寸的初始排列和比例的作用。实验持续时间足够短,以至于不会发生大规模分离,然而,我们发现,在所有条件下,径流都明显依赖于初始混合物的排列和比例。我们通过对流动前沿运动的详细分析来研究这一观察结果,识别出耗散占主导时的特征性“停止”阶段,并在流动前沿应用浅层模型来展示初始混合物的排列和比例如何影响就位过程中的有效摩擦系数。我们发现,双分散混合物在就位时能比单分散混合物产生更大的摩擦力,并且在显示出流动最大水平扩展的比例下,对于颗粒充分混合的初始排列,发现了最高的摩擦系数。这些观察结果表明,细颗粒在坍塌柱体的前沿向下渗透,因此流动前沿的局部尺寸分离过程可以控制流动的流动性。这种效应可能在控制有限时间尺度上发生的大型地球物理流的流动性方面很重要,并且其沉积物通常在前沿和边缘显示颗粒分离,但并非在整个沉积物中都如此。