Williams Stephen P, Howe Christopher L
Haynsworth Sinkler, Boyd, PA, USA.
J Healthc Risk Manag. 2013;32(4):35-42. doi: 10.1002/jhrm.21108.
Perhaps individual wishes are not always acknowledged or accepted when it comes to end-of-life care. This possibility, in conjunction with the experiences of healthcare risk managers, should cause concern in the healthcare risk management community. One particularly concerning issue where a persistent failure to honor a patient's wishes exists is with Do Not Resuscitate (DNR) orders in the perioperative arena. Despite a strong focus on informed consent and advance directives, evidence suggests a number of healthcare organizations either have no policy in place regarding DNR orders during the perioperative period, or, for those organizations that do have a policy, many call for automatic suspension of the DNR order without consultation with the patient. This latter practice poses many ethical, medico-legal, and regulatory concerns, and healthcare organizations with such a policy in place should strongly consider revisiting this practice.
在临终关怀方面,个人意愿可能并不总是得到认可或接受。这种可能性,再加上医疗风险管理专家的经验,应该引起医疗风险管理界的关注。围手术期领域的“不要复苏”(DNR)医嘱就是一个特别令人担忧的问题,在这个问题上,一直存在着不尊重患者意愿的情况。尽管人们高度重视知情同意和预先指示,但有证据表明,许多医疗机构在围手术期没有关于DNR医嘱的政策,或者对于那些有相关政策的机构来说,许多政策要求在未经患者协商的情况下自动暂停DNR医嘱。后一种做法引发了许多伦理、医疗法律和监管方面的担忧,实施这种政策的医疗机构应认真考虑重新审视这一做法。