Subhashree A R, Shanthi B
Associate Professor, Department of Pathology, Sree Balaji Medical College & Hospital, Bharath University , Chrompet, Chennai, Tamil nadu, India .
J Clin Diagn Res. 2013 Mar;7(3):496-8. doi: 10.7860/JCDR/2013/5250.2850. Epub 2013 Feb 15.
Second year undergraduate medical students lack an integrated approach towards the basic laboratory data. So, they find it difficult when analytical exercises are asked for in pathology practical examinations. A Complete Health Checkup (CHC) is one exercise where an individual undergoes a clinical examination, followed by various basic laboratory tests, along with other tests like ECG, X-ray and USG of the abdomen. A critical analysis of such charts would help in developing higher cognitive skills in the form of integration of all the data which is available, in order to arrive at a final diagnosis. We hypothesized that facilitating the students to analyze a set of clinical pathology tests by using CHC charts as modules would enhance their integrated approach towards the laboratory data.
To evaluate the use of pre designed complete health charts which were designed to enhance the students' ability to apply and integrate their knowledge on the clinical pathology data.
Two batches of 44 students each (Group 1 and Group 2), who attended the clinical pathology postings, were included in the study (totally 88 students). Informed consents were obtained from all of them. In addition to their routine posting schedules, the students in Group 2 were exposed to fifteen CHC charts, one at a time, with the subsequent analysis of each chart by using an objective test and a discussion. At the end of their clinical pathology postings, an OSPE was conducted for all the students and the test scores were analyzed. The statistical analysis was done using SPSS, version 15.
Group 1 obtained a score which ranged from 48% to 78%, with a mean±SE (mean) of 62.0% ± 1.21 and Group 2 obtained a score which ranged from 65% to 94%, with a mean±SE (mean) of 86.2% ± 0.96. The Student's-t-test for the equality of means with a value of 15.59 (p=0.000), implied a statistical significance in the mean score, as was observed between the two groups.
Facilitating the students' learning by using CHC charts helps in improving the students' capacity to analyze and interpret the clinical pathology data and so, it can be utilized on a routine basis.
本科二年级医学生缺乏对基础实验室数据的综合处理方法。因此,在病理学实践考试中要求进行分析练习时,他们会觉得困难。全面健康检查(CHC)是一项个人先接受临床检查,然后进行各种基础实验室检测,以及腹部心电图、X光和超声等其他检查的活动。对这类检查图表进行批判性分析,有助于以整合所有可用数据的形式培养更高的认知技能,从而得出最终诊断结果。我们假设,通过使用CHC图表作为模块来促使学生分析一组临床病理学检测结果,将增强他们对实验室数据的综合处理方法。
评估预先设计的全面健康图表的使用情况,这些图表旨在提高学生应用和整合临床病理学数据知识的能力。
本研究纳入了两批各44名学生(第1组和第2组),他们均参加了临床病理学实习(共88名学生)。所有学生均签署了知情同意书。除了常规实习安排外,第2组学生每次接触15份CHC图表,并通过客观测试和讨论对每份图表进行后续分析。在临床病理学实习结束时,对所有学生进行了客观结构化临床考试(OSPE)并分析了考试成绩。使用SPSS 15.0版进行统计分析。
第1组的成绩范围为48%至78%,平均±标准误(均值)为62.0% ± 1.21,第2组的成绩范围为65%至94%,平均±标准误(均值)为86.2% ± 0.96。两组均值相等性的学生t检验值为15.59(p = 0.000),表明两组的平均成绩具有统计学意义。
通过使用CHC图表促进学生学习有助于提高学生分析和解读临床病理学数据的能力,因此可在常规教学中加以利用。