Service de Chirurgie Hépatobiliaire et Digestive, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Rennes, Université de Rennes 1, Rennes, France.
J Gastrointest Surg. 2013 Jul;17(7):1247-56. doi: 10.1007/s11605-013-2215-4. Epub 2013 May 9.
The aim of this study was to retrospectively validate a new system to predict perihilar cholangiocarcinoma (PHC) resectability. We hypothesized that when the left lateral section (segments II-III) duct confluence (LLC) is free, the left lateral section might be preserved for curative resection. When the LLC is invaded, vascular invasion is frequent and radical resection might often be impossible without complex vascular reconstruction.
Radiological files of patients operated for PHC at our institution were reviewed and PHC was classified depending on whether LLC was invaded (type X) or free (type Y). Peroperative findings and follow-up were then matched with our XY classification.
Thirty-seven patients were included, 28 (78 %) type Y and nine (22 %) type X PHCs. Hepatic artery (HA) invasion was present in 14 % of type Y and 100 % of type X PHCs (P < 0.001). Left HA was never involved in type Y and always involved in type X. Portal vein invasion was present in 25 and 78 % of type Y and type X PHC, respectively (P = 0.014). Complete resection rates without HA in type Y and X patients were 89 % (84 % R0 and 16 % R1) and 33 % (37.5 % R0 and 12.5 % R1), respectively (P = 0.01). Sensitivity, specificity, and precision of the XY classification to predict resectability were 84, 67, and 84 %, respectively.
XY classification for PHCs suggests that in type Y (free LLC), the tumor is most often resectable, while in type X (LLC involved), the tumor is only resectable using complex vascular reconstructions.
本研究旨在回顾性验证一种新的系统来预测肝门部胆管癌(PHC)的可切除性。我们假设当左侧外侧段(II-III 段)胆管汇合(LLC)通畅时,左侧外侧段可能可以保留用于根治性切除。当 LLC 受侵犯时,常伴有血管侵犯,不进行复杂的血管重建则往往无法进行根治性切除。
回顾性分析我院接受 PHC 手术的患者的影像学资料,并根据 LLC 是否受侵犯(X 型)或通畅(Y 型)对 PHC 进行分类。然后将术中发现和随访结果与我们的 XY 分类相匹配。
共纳入 37 例患者,其中 28 例(78%)为 Y 型 PHC,9 例(22%)为 X 型 PHC。Y 型 PHC 肝动脉(HA)侵犯率为 14%,而 X 型 PHC 则为 100%(P<0.001)。Y 型中左 HA 从不受累,而 X 型中左 HA 总是受累。门静脉侵犯在 Y 型和 X 型 PHC 中的发生率分别为 25%和 78%(P=0.014)。Y 型和 X 型无 HA 患者的完全切除率分别为 89%(84%为 RO 切除,16%为 R1 切除)和 33%(37.5%为 RO 切除,12.5%为 R1 切除)(P=0.01)。XY 分类对可切除性的预测的敏感性、特异性和准确性分别为 84%、67%和 84%。
PHC 的 XY 分类提示,在 Y 型(LLC 通畅)中,肿瘤通常可切除,而在 X 型(LLC 受侵犯)中,只有通过复杂的血管重建才能切除肿瘤。