College of Dentistry, University of Tennessee Health Science Center, 875 Union Ave., Memphis, TN 38163, USA.
J Dent Educ. 2013 May;77(5):598-603.
This study investigated the possibility of teaching dental students to detect radiographic changes suggestive of osteoporosis. Twenty-five panoramic radiographs from dental school patients with a history of osteoporosis and radiographic changes suggestive of the disease and twenty-five normal panoramic radiographs were selected by a clinician from the database of the College of Dentistry, University of Tennessee Health Science Center. Twenty students were taught to use the mandibular cortical index (MCI) and detect changes suggestive of osteoporosis. Students also used a five-point scale to determine the diagnostic accuracy of panoramic images for osteoporosis. Intraclass Correlation Coefficient (ICCC) and Cronbach's alpha internal coefficiency statistical tests were used to evaluate interrater reliability among the twenty students and between the students and the radiologist. To test for differences in diagnosis between the gold standard (dental clinician) and the oral radiologist, we performed a McNemar's chi-square test for matched data. The interrater consistency was excellent for both the students (α=0.902) and between the students and the radiologist (α=0.909). The diagnostic accuracy of panoramic images was moderate (Az=0.81). No statistically significant difference between radiographic and clinical evaluations (McNemar's chi-square=3.063; p=0.0801) was observed. Teaching dental students to recognize radiographic changes suggestive of osteoporosis in routine panoramic radiographs should be emphasized to improve their awareness and identification of this disease.
本研究旨在探讨教授牙科学员检测提示骨质疏松症的放射影像学改变的可能性。临床医生从田纳西大学健康科学中心牙科学院的数据库中选择了 25 张来自骨质疏松症病史和提示该疾病放射影像学改变的牙科学员全景片,以及 25 张正常全景片。20 名学员被教授使用下颌皮质指数(MCI)并检测提示骨质疏松症的改变。学员还使用五分制量表来确定骨质疏松症全景图像的诊断准确性。使用组内相关系数(ICCC)和 Cronbach's alpha 内部系数统计检验来评估 20 名学员之间以及学员和放射科医生之间的评分者间可靠性。为了测试金标准(牙科临床医生)和口腔放射科医生之间诊断的差异,我们对匹配数据进行了 McNemar 的卡方检验。学员之间(α=0.902)和学员与放射科医生之间(α=0.909)的评分者间一致性均非常好。全景图像的诊断准确性为中度(Az=0.81)。未观察到放射学和临床评估之间存在统计学差异(McNemar 的卡方=3.063;p=0.0801)。应该强调教授牙科学员识别常规全景片中提示骨质疏松症的放射影像学改变,以提高他们对这种疾病的认识和识别能力。