School of Health and Population Sciences, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2013 May 2;8(5):e61979. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0061979. Print 2013.
Despite the proven efficacy of warfarin, its use in patients with Atrial Fibrillation (AF) is reportedly low. We investigated the underuse and overuse of warfarin in the management of AF in general practices in the United Kingdom (UK) against the National Institute of Clinical Excellence (NICE, UK) guidelines whilst seeking to identify subgroups of AF patients to inform efforts to optimise warfarin use.
A retrospective database analysis to determine warfarin prescribing using tree models based on 50,361 patients with AF (classified as low, moderate and high risk of stroke using CHADS2) from 430 general practices in the UK.
Over one-third (37.0%, 4573/12,351) of low risk AF patients were on warfarin, compared with 47.1% (8349/17,709) moderate risk AF patients and 54.9% (11,142/20,301) high risk AF patients. Clinical subgroups (n = 15 low risk subgroups, n = 15 medium risk subgroups, n = 22 high risk subgroups) were identified. Several factors not supported by current guidelines (age, BMI, dementia, gender) were associated with the use of warfarin. Gender and BMI were associated with warfarin use in low and medium risk AF patients but not in high risk AF patients.
Whilst NICE guidelines suggest that all high risk AF patients should be on warfarin, half of those at moderate risk should be on warfarin and none of those at low risk should be on warfarin, we found evidence of over and under use of warfarin. Interventions to optimise warfarin therapy tailored to and targeting specific subgroups of AF patients identified by the tree models are required.
尽管华法林已被证实有效,但据报道,其在心房颤动(AF)患者中的使用情况较低。我们调查了英国(UK)普通实践中对抗凝治疗的不充分使用和过度使用情况,以评估其是否符合国家临床卓越研究所(NICE,英国)的指南,同时试图确定 AF 患者亚组,以优化华法林的使用。
通过基于英国 430 家普通实践中 50361 名 AF 患者(使用 CHADS2 评分对中风风险进行低、中、高分类)的树模型进行回顾性数据库分析,以确定华法林的使用情况。
与低风险 AF 患者中的 37.0%(4573/12351)相比,47.1%(8349/17709)中度风险 AF 患者和 54.9%(11142/20301)高风险 AF 患者接受了华法林治疗。确定了临床亚组(n=15 个低风险亚组,n=15 个中等风险亚组,n=22 个高风险亚组)。一些与当前指南不相符的因素(年龄、BMI、痴呆、性别)与华法林的使用有关。性别和 BMI 与低危和中危 AF 患者的华法林使用有关,但与高危 AF 患者无关。
尽管 NICE 指南建议所有高危 AF 患者都应使用华法林,但半数中度风险患者应使用华法林,且无低危患者应使用华法林,但我们发现华法林使用存在过度和不足的情况。需要针对通过树模型确定的 AF 患者特定亚组进行优化华法林治疗的干预措施。