Department of Otorhinolaryngology, University of Southern Denmark, Odense, Denmark.
Rhinology. 2013 Jun;51(2):128-36. doi: 10.4193/Rhino12.029.
The European Position Paper on Rhinosinusitis and Nasal Polyps (EP3OS) incorporates symptomatic and endo- scopic criteria in the clinical diagnosis of chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS), while in epidemiological studies the definition is based on symptoms only. The aim of this study was to evaluate the correlation between questionnaire-based and clinical-based CRS.
Based on the GA2LEN postal survey data a total of 366 persons participated at the follow-up at the Danish centre and provided information on questionnaire-based CRS. At the same occasion the 366 participants underwent clinical inter- view and examination by an otorhinolaryngologist to provide information for a clinical-based CRS diagnosis. The association between questionnaire-based and clinical-based CRS diagnosis was determined using logistic regression models and kappa statistics.
Mean age of respondents to the postal questionnaire was 45.3 years and 52.9% were female. Persons with asthma were 8.4 % and 26.2 % were actual smokers. There was moderate agreement between questionnaire-based and clinical-based CRS. Sensitivity was [corrected] low comparing questionnaire-based CRS with clinical-based CRS. Incorporation of self reported CRS and medical history in diagnosing CRS by questionnaire increased increased [corrected] the agreement and sensitivity while specificity stayed at a high level. [corrected]
Evaluating the correlation between questionnaire-based and clinical-based CRS showed only moderate agree- ment and questions whether they evaluate the same disease. It brings into consideration that adjustments are needed to justify correlation between questionnaire-based and clinical-based diagnosis of CRS.
欧洲鼻窦炎和鼻息肉诊疗意见书(EP3OS)将症状和内镜标准纳入慢性鼻窦炎(CRS)的临床诊断中,而在流行病学研究中,定义则仅基于症状。本研究旨在评估基于问卷和基于临床的 CRS 之间的相关性。
基于 GA2LEN 邮寄调查数据,共有 366 人参加了丹麦中心的随访,并提供了基于问卷的 CRS 信息。同时,这 366 名参与者接受了耳鼻喉科医生的临床访谈和检查,以提供临床 CRS 诊断信息。使用逻辑回归模型和 Kappa 统计来确定基于问卷和基于临床的 CRS 诊断之间的关联。
邮寄问卷的受访者的平均年龄为 45.3 岁,女性占 52.9%。哮喘患者占 8.4%,实际吸烟者占 26.2%。基于问卷和基于临床的 CRS 之间存在中度一致性。与基于临床的 CRS 相比,基于问卷的 CRS 的敏感性较低。通过问卷纳入自我报告的 CRS 和病史来诊断 CRS,可提高一致性和敏感性,而特异性仍保持在较高水平。
评估基于问卷和基于临床的 CRS 之间的相关性表明,两者仅存在中度一致性,这引发了对它们是否评估同一疾病的质疑。这使得有必要对基于问卷和临床诊断 CRS 的相关性进行调整。