Simborg D W, Starfield B H, Horn S D
Am J Public Health. 1978 Jan;68(1):44-8. doi: 10.2105/ajph.68.1.44.
Six primary care practices which utilize both physician and non-physician practitioner types were studied to measure differences between practitioner types in the care of patients. By chart review 1,369 patient-practitioner encounters were examined. Physicians identified less symptoms and signs in their patients and prescribed less non-drug therapies than did non-physicians. Likewise, at follow-up visits, physicians tended to document less follow-up of these types of problems and therapies than non-physicians. When examining the interaction between practitioners, the highest rates of follow-up of all types of problems and therapies were found when the same practitioner saw the patient at two successive visits to the same clinic. When a physician saw a patient following a previous visit to a nurse practitioner, there was a significant drop-off in the follow-up rate of problems and therapies. However, when a nurse practitioner saw the patient following a previous visit to a physician, the drop-off in follow-up rates was not as striking. These findings indicate that the skills of physician and nonphysician practitioners are potentially complementary. However, this potential is not fully exploited, particularly by physicians.
对六家同时使用医生和非医生从业者的基层医疗诊所进行了研究,以衡量不同类型从业者在患者护理方面的差异。通过病历审查,检查了1369次患者与从业者的诊疗接触。与非医生相比,医生发现患者的症状和体征较少,开具的非药物治疗也较少。同样,在随访就诊时,医生记录的这类问题和治疗的随访情况往往比非医生少。在检查从业者之间的互动时,当同一名从业者在同一家诊所连续两次就诊时看到患者,所有类型问题和治疗的随访率最高。当医生在患者先前就诊于执业护士之后再看该患者时,问题和治疗的随访率会显著下降。然而,当执业护士在患者先前就诊于医生之后再看该患者时,随访率的下降并不那么明显。这些发现表明,医生和非医生从业者的技能可能具有互补性。然而,这种潜力并未得到充分利用,尤其是医生。