University of Michigan School of Social Work, 1080 S. University Ave., Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA.
J Dent Res. 2013 Jul;92(7 Suppl):11S-5S. doi: 10.1177/0022034513484333. Epub 2013 May 20.
Dental therapists are members of the dental team in many countries, where they perform a limited number of irreversible restorative procedures. In the United States, they practice only in Alaska and Minnesota, though other states are considering adding them in an effort to improve access to care. While critics of this workforce model cite concern for patient safety, proponents argue that dental therapists provide treatment that is as technically competent as that provided by dentists. Though nearly 2 dozen studies from industrialized countries address this subject, this article systematically reviews all 23 of them. Of these reports, all but 2 conclude that dental therapists perform at an acceptable level. Every study that directly compared the work of dental therapists with that of dentists found that they performed at least as well. Regardless of whether dental therapists would be the most effective intervention for improving access to oral health care in the United States, the evidence clearly suggests dental therapists are clinically competent to safely perform the limited set of procedures that falls within their scope of practice.
在许多国家,牙科治疗师是牙科团队的成员,他们执行有限数量的不可逆修复程序。在美国,他们仅在阿拉斯加和明尼苏达州执业,尽管其他州也在考虑加入他们,以努力改善获得护理的机会。虽然这种劳动力模式的批评者对患者安全表示担忧,但支持者认为,牙科治疗师提供的治疗在技术上与牙医提供的治疗一样胜任。尽管来自工业化国家的近 24 项研究都涉及到这个主题,但本文系统地回顾了其中的 23 项。在这些报告中,除了 2 项之外,其余的都得出结论认为,牙科治疗师的表现是可以接受的。每一项直接比较牙科治疗师和牙医工作的研究都发现,他们的表现至少同样出色。无论牙科治疗师是否是改善美国口腔保健服务可及性的最有效干预措施,证据清楚地表明,牙科治疗师在临床方面有能力安全地执行属于其执业范围的有限程序。