Ferran Nicholas Antonio, Ball Luke, Maffulli Nicola
Department of Trauma & Orthopaedics, Leicester Royal Infirmary, UK.
Muscles Ligaments Tendons J. 2013 Jan 21;2(4):278-81. Print 2012 Oct.
This study determined whether the orientation of dorsoplantar and oblique foot radiographs has an effect on radiograph interpretation. A test set of 50 consecutive foot radiographs were selected (25 with fractures, and 25 normal), and duplicated in the horizontal orientation. The images were randomly arranged, numbered 1 through 100, and analysed by six image interpreters. Vertical and horizontal area under the ROC curve, accuracy, sensitivity and specificity were calculated for each image interpreter. There was no significant difference in the area under the ROC curve, accuracy, sensitivity or specificity of image interpretation between images viewed in the vertical or horizontal orientation. While conventions for display of radiographs may help to improve the development of an efficient visual search strategy in trainees, and allow for standardisation of publication of radiographic images, variation from the convention in clinical practice does not appear to affect the sensitivity or specificity of image interpretation.
本研究确定了足背跖侧和斜位X线片的方向是否会对X线片解读产生影响。选取了连续50例足部X线片的测试集(25例有骨折,25例正常),并复制为水平方向。图像随机排列,编号为1至100,由6名图像解读人员进行分析。计算每名图像解读人员的ROC曲线下垂直和水平面积、准确性、敏感性和特异性。垂直或水平方向观察的图像之间,图像解读的ROC曲线下面积、准确性、敏感性或特异性均无显著差异。虽然X线片的显示规范可能有助于提高实习生有效视觉搜索策略的发展,并使X线图像的发表标准化,但临床实践中与规范的差异似乎不会影响图像解读的敏感性或特异性。