Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Yonsei University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
Clin Otolaryngol. 2013 Jun;38(3):225-30. doi: 10.1111/coa.12117.
To compare the efficacies of a thermosensitive poloxamer (TPX) and Merogel in preventing adhesion applied after the removal of nasal packing in endoscopic sinus surgery as a non-inferiority trial.
Randomised, multicentre, single-blind, active-controlled, matched-pair study.
Yonsei University Gangnam Severance Hospital, Korea University Guro Hospital.
A total of 70 patients were enroled and underwent endoscopic sinus surgeries. Four of the patients did not complete their follow-up. Analysis of the 66 enroled patients having completed postoperative assessment was performed. The severity of rhinosinusitis was graded with a Lund-McKay CT score, and only those with bilateral disease and a CT score difference ≤2 between sinuses were included.
An independent rhinologist from a third institution through a blinded assessment with digital photoendoscopy of the middle meati bilaterally taken postoperatively.
In the blinded assessment, thermosensitive poloxamer (anti-adhesion rate: 92%) was similar to Merogel (anti-adhesion rate: 89%). Evaluation of the presence and grade of adhesion, oedema, and infection in the middle meatus revealed no significant differences between the thermosensitive poloxamer group and the Merogel group at all postoperative periods.
Anti-adhesive effects of thermosensitive poloxamer are similar to those of Merogel. Therefore, thermosensitive poloxamer can be considered a safe alternative to Merogel for preventing adhesion in patients undergoing endoscopic sinus surgeries, and further evaluation of thermosensitive poloxamer as an anti-adhesive and primary packing material compared with the control using no packing is needed.
比较温敏型泊洛沙姆(TPX)和 Merogel 在鼻内镜鼻窦手术后去除填塞物后预防粘连的疗效,进行非劣效性试验。
随机、多中心、单盲、阳性对照、配对研究。
韩国延世大学江南Severance 医院、韩国大学古罗医院。
共纳入 70 例患者行鼻内镜鼻窦手术。其中 4 例患者未完成随访。对完成术后评估的 66 例纳入患者进行分析。采用 Lund-McKay CT 评分评估鼻窦炎严重程度,仅纳入双侧病变且鼻窦 CT 评分差异≤2 的患者。
由第三家机构的独立鼻科医生通过双侧中鼻甲的数字鼻内镜盲法评估。
在盲法评估中,温敏型泊洛沙姆(防粘连率:92%)与 Merogel(防粘连率:89%)相似。对中鼻甲的粘连、水肿和感染存在及严重程度的评估显示,温敏型泊洛沙姆组和 Merogel 组在所有术后时期均无显著差异。
温敏型泊洛沙姆的防粘连效果与 Merogel 相似。因此,温敏型泊洛沙姆可作为预防鼻内镜鼻窦手术患者粘连的一种安全替代物,需要进一步评估温敏型泊洛沙姆作为防粘连和主要填塞物的效果,与不使用填塞物的对照进行比较。