School of Nursing, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Nurs Philos. 2013 Jul;14(3):178-85. doi: 10.1111/nup.12017.
The purpose of this paper is to engage with the readers in a theoretical reflection on nursing practices in forensic psychiatric settings. In this paper, we argue that practices of exclusion in forensic psychiatric settings share some common ground with Agamben's description of sovereign power and, consequently, the possible creation of zones of exception in this environment. The concept of exception is, therefore, purposely used to shift our thinking, highlight the political forces surrounding exclusionary practices in forensic psychiatric nursing, and explore the ethical tensions that arise for nurses who become entangled in the control of these zones of exception. We argue that ethical and political discussions regarding this phenomenon are necessary if we wish to further understand the complexities of this field of practice and promote constructive change.
本文旨在与读者进行理论反思,探讨法医精神病学环境中的护理实践。在本文中,我们认为法医精神病学环境中的排斥实践与阿甘本对主权权力的描述有一些共同之处,因此,在这种环境中可能会产生例外区域。因此,故意使用例外概念来改变我们的思维方式,突出法医精神病学护理中排斥性实践所围绕的政治力量,并探讨陷入这些例外区域控制的护士所面临的伦理紧张局势。我们认为,如果我们希望进一步了解这一实践领域的复杂性并推动建设性变革,那么就必须对这一现象进行伦理和政治讨论。