Department of Oncology, Radiation Oncology, University of Torino, Torino, Italy.
Technol Cancer Res Treat. 2014 Feb;13(1):37-45. doi: 10.7785/tcrt.2012.500355. Epub 2013 Jun 24.
Stereotactic Ablative Radiotherapy (SABR) has been previously investigated as an alternative to thoracic surgery in patients with a limited number of pulmonary nodules from different primary tumors. We here report the clinical outcomes of a series of consecutive patients homogeneously selected and treated with single dose SABR in our Institution. Eligibility criteria were: 1-5 lung metastases, maximum tumor diameter <50 mm, absent or controlled extra-thoracic disease, adequate pulmonary function, no prior radiotherapy, performance status ECOG 0-1. All patients were treated with a single dose of 26 Gy prescribed to the 80% isodose, by 3D-CRT or by IGRT-VMAT. Follow-up consisted of clinical evaluation and periodic CT scans. Primary endpoints were Local Control (LC), toxicity and Progression-Free Survival (PFS). Secondary endpoints were Cancer-Specific Survival (CSS) and Overall Survival (OS). Out of 102 patients treated with SABR between october 2003 and october 2011, we selected 67 patients for a total of 90 lesions. Main primary tumor sites were lung and colon-rectum (37.3% and 43.3% of lesions, respectively). Median follow up time was 24 months. Treated metastasis progression at SABR site was observed in 10 lesions (11.1%), and actuarial LC rates at 1 and 2 years were respectively 93.4% and 88.1%. Systemic failure occurred in 37 patients (55.2%) at a median interval of 8 months after SABR. PFS rates were 72% and 55.4% at 1 and 2 year. Seven patients had grade 1 (10.4%) and 8 grade 2-3 late radiological toxicity (11.9%), while 6 experienced late chest wall toxicity (2 rib fractures, 4 chronic chest pain, 8.9%). CSS rates at 1 and 2 years were 90% and 76%, while OS rates were 85.1% and 70.5%, respectively. Median survival time was 40 months. On multivariate analysis, a disease-free interval longer than 24 months was close to significance for a benefit in CSS (p = 0.07; HR 0.34 [95% CI 0.1-1.12]). The study includes a cohort of patients treated with single fraction 26 Gy SABR followed for a prolonged time interval. Single fraction SABR appears to be an effective treatment option, with little observed acute toxicity and limited late toxicity (<15%); its advantages also include a high patients' compliance, a short overall treatment time and an easy combination with systemic therapies. These results might provide supportive evidence to the use of single fraction SABR as a valid and acceptable alternative to surgery for pulmonary metastases from different primary tumors.
立体定向消融放疗 (SABR) 已被先前研究作为治疗不同原发性肿瘤肺转移患者的一种替代方法,这些患者的肺部存在数量有限的多个结节。我们在此报告在我们机构中连续选择并接受单次剂量 SABR 治疗的一系列患者的临床结果。入选标准为:1-5 个肺转移灶,最大肿瘤直径<50mm,无或控制的胸外疾病,肺功能正常,无放疗史,ECOG 体能状态 0-1。所有患者均接受 26Gy 的单次剂量照射,80%的等剂量曲线覆盖肿瘤,采用 3D-CRT 或 IGRT-VMAT 进行治疗。随访包括临床评估和定期 CT 扫描。主要终点是局部控制 (LC)、毒性和无进展生存期 (PFS)。次要终点是癌症特异性生存期 (CSS) 和总生存期 (OS)。在 2003 年 10 月至 2011 年 10 月期间,我们使用 SABR 治疗了 102 例患者,从中选择了 67 例患者,共 90 个病灶。主要原发性肿瘤部位为肺和结肠直肠 (分别为 37.3%和 43.3%的病灶)。中位随访时间为 24 个月。在 SABR 部位观察到 10 个病灶 (11.1%)的治疗性转移进展,1 年和 2 年的局部控制率分别为 93.4%和 88.1%。在 SABR 后中位 8 个月时,37 例患者 (55.2%)发生全身转移。1 年和 2 年的无进展生存率分别为 72%和 55.4%。7 例患者发生 1 级 (10.4%)和 8 例 2-3 级晚期放射学毒性 (11.9%),6 例发生晚期胸壁毒性 (2 例肋骨骨折,4 例慢性胸痛,8.9%)。1 年和 2 年的 CSS 率分别为 90%和 76%,OS 率分别为 85.1%和 70.5%。中位生存时间为 40 个月。多因素分析显示,无疾病间隔时间>24 个月与 CSS 获益接近显著相关 (p=0.07; HR 0.34 [95%CI 0.1-1.12])。该研究包括一组接受单次 26Gy SABR 治疗并进行了长时间随访的患者。单次分割 SABR 似乎是一种有效的治疗选择,观察到的急性毒性较小,晚期毒性有限(<15%);其优点还包括患者的高依从性、总治疗时间短以及易于与全身治疗相结合。这些结果可能为单次分割 SABR 作为治疗不同原发性肿瘤肺转移的一种有效且可接受的替代手术方法提供支持性证据。