1Faculty of Rehabilitation, Kobe Gakuin University, Kobe, Japan.
Clin Rehabil. 2014 Jan;28(1):48-58. doi: 10.1177/0269215513492161. Epub 2013 Jul 3.
To investigate the effects of high-velocity resistance training on muscle function, muscle properties, and physical performance in patients with hip osteoarthritis by comparison with those of low-velocity resistance training.
Single-blind randomized controlled trial.
Home-based exercise programmes.
A total of 46 women with hip osteoarthritis were randomly assigned to the high-velocity (n = 23) or low-velocity (n = 23) training group.
Both groups underwent an eight-week daily home-based resistance training programme using an elastic band. Exercises involved hip abduction, extension, and flexion and knee extension. Participants in the high-velocity group performed the concentric phase of each repetition as rapidly as possible and returned to the initial position eccentrically in 3 s. Participants in the low-velocity group performed both the concentric and eccentric phases in 3 s.
The following outcome measures were evaluated: isometric muscle strength, muscle power, muscle thickness, muscle echo intensity, maximum walking speed, Timed Up and Go test, 3-minute walking test, Harris Hip Score, and hip pain.
Decreases in the time for performing the Timed Up and Go test (mean changes: high-velocity group -0.46 s, low-velocity group -0.23 s) and echo intensity of the gluteus maximus (mean changes: high-velocity group -6.8, low-velocity group -1.0) were significantly greater in the high-velocity group than in the low-velocity group. No significant difference was observed in changes of other outcome measures between the groups.
This study revealed that high-velocity training for patients with hip osteoarthritis has partially a greater effect on muscle properties and physical performance than low-velocity training.
通过与低速度阻力训练相比,研究高速阻力训练对髋关节炎患者肌肉功能、肌肉特性和身体表现的影响。
单盲随机对照试验。
家庭运动方案。
共有 46 名髋关节炎女性患者被随机分配到高速(n = 23)或低速(n = 23)训练组。
两组均接受为期 8 周的家庭基础弹性带阻力训练计划。练习包括髋关节外展、伸展和屈曲以及膝关节伸展。高速组的参与者以最快的速度完成每个重复的向心阶段,并在 3 秒内以离心方式返回初始位置。低速组的参与者在 3 秒内完成向心和离心阶段。
评估以下结果指标:等长肌肉力量、肌肉力量、肌肉厚度、肌肉回声强度、最大步行速度、计时起立行走测试、3 分钟步行测试、髋关节评分和髋部疼痛。
在完成计时起立行走测试的时间(高速组平均变化-0.46 秒,低速组平均变化-0.23 秒)和臀大肌回声强度(高速组平均变化-6.8,低速组平均变化-1.0)方面,高速组的变化明显大于低速组。两组间其他结果指标的变化无显著差异。
本研究表明,髋关节炎患者的高速训练对肌肉特性和身体表现的影响部分大于低速训练。