Division of Emergency Medicine, Department of Pediatrics, CHU Sainte-Justine, Université de Montréal, Montréal, Québec.
Pediatr Neurol. 2013 Jul;49(1):40-5. doi: 10.1016/j.pediatrneurol.2013.03.003.
Migraine criteria lack sensitivity in children and are not designed to be used in the emergency department. This study's aim was to compare the diagnosis of migraine in children with moderate to severe headache made by pediatric emergency physicians to the International Classification of Headache Disorders II migraine criteria with annotation for children and a new criteria, the Irma emergency department criteria, using the neurologist's diagnosis as the gold standard.
This was part of a prospective study with a convenience sample of patients <18 years old, diagnosed with migraine by pediatric emergency physicians and treated with intravenous medication due to severity of symptoms. A standardized questionnaire on the patient's present and past headaches description was completed by the patient and his or her family during their stay in the emergency department. Each patient was assessed by a pediatric neurologist within 3 months to confirm the final diagnosis.
Between July 2007 and July 2009, 79 children completed a questionnaire. Of these, 11 were not evaluated by the neurologist (eight never reported for follow-up and three were not referred). Of the remaining, four had another final diagnosis, leaving 64 (94%) patients with confirmed diagnoses of migraine. Among these patients, 29 (45%) had headaches that fulfilled the International Classification of Headache Disorders II migraine criteria with annotation for children and 55 (86%) fulfilled the new criteria, the Irma emergency department criteria.
Physicians' clinical judgment performed better than the published migraine criteria, which did not have adequate sensitivity to be of use to pediatric emergency physicians.
偏头痛的诊断标准在儿童中不够敏感,也不是专门为在急诊部门使用而设计的。本研究的目的是比较儿科急诊医生对中度至重度头痛的儿童偏头痛的诊断与国际头痛疾病分类第二版偏头痛标准(带儿童注释)以及新的 Irma 急诊标准,以神经病学家的诊断为金标准。
这是一项前瞻性研究的一部分,采用方便抽样法,选取了 79 名因症状严重而由儿科急诊医生诊断为偏头痛并接受静脉药物治疗的 <18 岁患者。患者及其家属在急诊逗留期间完成了一份关于患者目前和过去头痛描述的标准化问卷。每位患者在 3 个月内由儿科神经科医生进行评估以确认最终诊断。
2007 年 7 月至 2009 年 7 月,79 名儿童完成了问卷。其中 11 名未由神经病学家评估(8 名从未进行随访,3 名未被转诊)。在其余的儿童中,有 4 名有其他最终诊断,因此,有 64 名(94%)偏头痛诊断得到证实的患者。在这些患者中,29 名(45%)的头痛符合国际头痛疾病分类第二版偏头痛标准(带儿童注释),55 名(86%)符合新的 Irma 急诊标准。
医生的临床判断优于发表的偏头痛标准,后者对儿科急诊医生来说敏感性不够。