Center for Health Protection, National Institute for Public Health and the Environment-RIVM, 3720 BA, Bilthoven, The Netherlands.
Toxicol Lett. 2013 Aug 29;221(3):225-36. doi: 10.1016/j.toxlet.2013.06.236. Epub 2013 Jul 3.
In vitro models for hepatotoxicity testing are a necessity for advancement of toxicological research. Assessing the in vitro response requires in vivo validated gene sets reflective of the hepatotoxic phenotype. Cholestasis, the impairment of bile flow, is induced in C57BL/6J mice treated with cyclosporine A (CsA) to identify phenotype reflective gene sets. CsA treatment through oral gavage for 25 days induced cholestasis, as confirmed by histopathology and serum chemistry. Over 1, 4, and 11 days of CsA exposure gradual increases in serum markers were correlated to gene expression. This phenotype-directed analysis identified gene sets specific to the onset and progression of cholestasis, such as PPAR related processes and drug metabolism, by circumventing other effects of CsA, such as immunosuppression, found in dose*time group analysis. In vivo gene sets are enriched in publicly available data sets of CsA-treated HepaRG and primary mouse hepatocytes. However, genes identified within these gene sets did not overlap between in vivo and in vitro. In vitro regulated genes represent the initial response to cholestasis, whereas in vivo genes represent the later adaptive response. We conclude that the applicability of in vitro models for hepatotoxicity testing fully depends on a solid in vivo phenotype anchored analysis.
体外肝细胞毒性测试模型是毒理学研究进展的必要条件。评估体外反应需要体内验证的基因集,以反映肝细胞毒性表型。采用环孢素 A(CsA)处理 C57BL/6J 小鼠诱导胆汁淤积,以确定反映表型的基因集。通过口服灌胃 25 天的 CsA 处理,通过组织病理学和血清化学证实了胆汁淤积的诱导。在 CsA 暴露的 1、4 和 11 天中,血清标志物的逐渐增加与基因表达相关。这种表型导向的分析通过避免 CsA 的其他作用(例如在剂量-时间组分析中发现的免疫抑制作用),确定了与胆汁淤积的发生和进展相关的特定基因集,例如 PPAR 相关过程和药物代谢。体内基因集在公开的 CsA 处理 HepaRG 和原代小鼠肝细胞的数据集丰富。然而,这些基因集中鉴定的基因在体内和体外之间没有重叠。体外调节基因代表对胆汁淤积的初始反应,而体内基因代表后期的适应性反应。我们得出结论,体外肝细胞毒性测试模型的适用性完全取决于基于体内表型的可靠分析。