Centre for Health Protection, National Institute for Public Health and the Environment (RIVM), PO Box 1, 3720 BA, Bilthoven, The Netherlands.
Arch Toxicol. 2013 May;87(5):807-23. doi: 10.1007/s00204-013-1039-z. Epub 2013 Apr 6.
The whole zebrafish embryo model (ZFE) has proven its applicability in developmental toxicity testing. Since functional hepatocytes are already present from 36 h post fertilization onwards, whole ZFE have been proposed as an attractive alternative to mammalian in vivo models in hepatotoxicity testing. The goal of the present study is to further underpin the applicability of whole ZFE for hepatotoxicity testing by combining histopathology and next-generation sequencing-based gene expression profiling. To this aim, whole ZFE and adult zebrafish were exposed to a set of hepatotoxic reference compounds. Histopathology revealed compound and life-stage-specific effects indicative of toxic injury in livers of whole ZFE and adult zebrafish. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) was used to compare transcript profiles in pooled individual RNA samples of whole ZFE and livers of adult zebrafish. This revealed that hepatotoxicity-associated expression can be detected beyond the overall transcription noise in the whole embryo. In situ hybridization verified liver specificity of selected highly expressed markers in whole ZFE. Finally, cyclosporine A (CsA) was used as an illustrative case to support applicability of ZFE in hepatotoxicity testing by comparing CsA-induced gene expression between ZFE, in vivo mouse liver and HepaRG cells on the levels of single genes, pathways and transcription factors. While there was no clear overlap on single gene level between the whole ZFE and in vivo mouse liver, strong similarities were observed between whole ZFE and in vivo mouse liver in regulated pathways related to hepatotoxicity, as well as in relevant overrepresented transcription factors. In conclusion, both the use of NGS of pooled RNA extracts analysis combined with histopathology and traditional microarray in single case showed the potential to detect liver-related genes and processes within the transcriptome of a whole zebrafish embryo. This supports the applicability of the whole ZFE model for compound-induced hepatotoxicity screening.
整体斑马鱼胚胎模型(ZFE)已被证明在发育毒性测试中具有适用性。由于从受精后 36 小时开始就已经存在功能性肝细胞,因此整体 ZFE 已被提议作为在肝毒性测试中替代哺乳动物体内模型的有吸引力的替代方法。本研究的目的是通过结合组织病理学和基于下一代测序的基因表达谱分析,进一步支持整体 ZFE 在肝毒性测试中的适用性。为此,将整体 ZFE 和成年斑马鱼暴露于一组肝毒性参考化合物中。组织病理学显示,化合物和生命阶段特异性效应表明整体 ZFE 和成年斑马鱼肝脏中的毒性损伤。下一代测序(NGS)用于比较整体 ZFE 个体 RNA 样本的 pooled 和成年斑马鱼肝脏的转录谱。这表明可以在整个胚胎的总体转录噪声之外检测到与肝毒性相关的表达。原位杂交验证了所选在整体 ZFE 中高度表达标记的肝脏特异性。最后,环孢素 A(CsA)被用作说明性案例,通过比较 ZFE、体内小鼠肝脏和 HepaRG 细胞在单个基因、途径和转录因子水平上的 CsA 诱导基因表达,来支持 ZFE 在肝毒性测试中的适用性。虽然整体 ZFE 和体内小鼠肝脏在单个基因水平上没有明显重叠,但在与肝毒性相关的调节途径以及相关的过表达转录因子方面,整体 ZFE 和体内小鼠肝脏之间存在很强的相似性。总之,使用 NGS 对 pooled RNA 提取物进行分析,结合组织病理学和单个病例中的传统微阵列,显示出在整个斑马鱼胚胎转录组中检测与肝脏相关的基因和过程的潜力。这支持了整体 ZFE 模型在化合物诱导肝毒性筛选中的适用性。