Tan Stephan P K, Proctor Mark R, Mulliken John B, Rogers Gary F
Departments of Plastic and Oral Surgery, Boston Children's Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
J Craniofac Surg. 2013 Jul;24(4):1190-4. doi: 10.1097/SCS.0b013e318299742e.
Frontoorbital advancement (FOA) improves forehead and superior orbital asymmetry associated with unilateral coronal synostosis but has little effect on facial asymmetry. This study compares frontofacial symmetry after FOA and endoscopically assisted suturectomy (ESC) and postoperative helmet therapy.A retrospective review of 2 cohorts of patients with nonsyndromic unilateral coronal synostosis who had either FOA or ESC was undertaken. Choice of procedure was determined by age of patient at referral (younger than 4 months, FOA or ESC; older than 4 months, only FOA). Vectra 3D imaging system (Canfield Imaging Systems, Fairfield, NJ) was used to capture and analyze three-dimensional digital images. Comparative anthropometric measurements were made and statistically analyzed.Twenty-two patients met the inclusion criteria; 11 underwent ESC at mean age of 2 months (range, 1-4 months) and 11 underwent FOA at mean age of 12 months (range, 8-25 months). Mean age at three-dimensional digital imaging was 45.9 months (range, 18-64 months) for the FOA group and 34.5 months (range, 20-66 months) for the ESC group (P = 0.054).There was no difference between the 2 groups with regard to supraorbital symmetry (P = 0.54). The ESC group exhibited better facial symmetry in midline deviation (3.6° vs 1.4°; P = 0.018), nasal tip deviation (5.6° vs 2.3°; P = 0.006), and middle facial depth (6.9 vs 4.4 mm; P = 0.042). Lower facial depth was similar (3.8 vs 2.3 mm; P = 0.54).Early ESC and helmet therapy results in comparable brow symmetry and better overall facial symmetry than FOA done in late infancy.
额眶前移术(FOA)可改善与单侧冠状缝早闭相关的前额和眶上不对称,但对面部不对称影响较小。本研究比较了FOA与内镜辅助缝扎切除术(ESC)及术后头盔治疗后的面中部对称性。
对两组非综合征性单侧冠状缝早闭患者进行回顾性研究,一组接受FOA,另一组接受ESC。手术方式的选择取决于转诊时患者的年龄(4个月以下,FOA或ESC;4个月以上,仅FOA)。使用Vectra 3D成像系统(Canfield Imaging Systems,Fairfield,NJ)采集和分析三维数字图像。进行比较人体测量并进行统计分析。
22例患者符合纳入标准;11例平均年龄2个月(范围1 - 4个月)时接受ESC,11例平均年龄12个月(范围8 - 25个月)时接受FOA。FOA组三维数字成像的平均年龄为45.9个月(范围18 - 64个月),ESC组为34.5个月(范围20 - 66个月)(P = 0.054)。
两组眶上对称性无差异(P = 0.54)。ESC组在中线偏差(3.6°对1.4°;P = 0.018)、鼻尖偏差(5.6°对2.3°;P = 0.006)和中面部深度(6.9对4.4 mm;P = 0.042)方面表现出更好的面部对称性。下颌面部深度相似(3.8对2.3 mm;P = 0.54)。
早期ESC和头盔治疗与婴儿晚期进行的FOA相比,可获得相当的眉部对称性和更好的整体面部对称性。