Collett Brent R, Gray Kristen E, Kapp-Simon Kathleen A, Birgfeld Craig, Cunningham Michael, Rudo-Stern Jenna, Ung Danielle, Buono Lauren, Speltz Matthew L
Psychiatry and Behavioral Medicine, Seattle Children's Hospital, Seattle, WA 98121, USA.
J Craniofac Surg. 2013 Jul;24(4):1331-5. doi: 10.1097/SCS.0b013e3182997885.
Single-suture craniosynostosis (SSC) results in head shape anomalies that likely affect social perceptions of appearance. The purpose of this study was to evaluate laypersons' ratings of attractiveness in children with and without SSC. Among cases, we also examined differences by suture fused and age at surgery.
We collected photographs of 196 children with SSC and 186 children without SSC as infants (before surgery, for cases) and at ages 18 and 36 months. Photographs were rated by 8 raters, who were blinded to the population being studied. We used linear regression to compare appearance ratings for the 2 groups at each visit and to evaluate changes over time. Regression analyses were used to examine the association between age at surgery and appearance ratings.
Children with SSC received lower appearance ratings than unaffected controls at each visit (all P < 0.001). Appearance ratings decreased over time, with a similar trajectory for children with and without SSC. Among cases, those with unicoronal and lambdoid synostosis had the lowest ratings and those with sagittal synostosis had the highest. Age at surgery was inversely associated with appearance ratings.
Children with SSC received lower appearance ratings than unaffected controls, with minimal change after surgery. Better outcomes were associated with earlier surgery. These findings do not indicate that children with SSC failed to benefit from surgery, as without surgical intervention, asymmetrical head shape would likely have worsened over time. However, our data suggest that appearance does not fully "normalize."
单缝颅缝早闭(SSC)会导致头部形状异常,这可能会影响社会对外貌的认知。本研究的目的是评估普通大众对患有和未患有SSC的儿童的吸引力评分。在病例中,我们还按融合的缝和手术时的年龄检查了差异。
我们收集了196例患有SSC的儿童和186例未患有SSC的儿童在婴儿期(对于病例为手术前)以及18个月和36个月大时的照片。照片由8名评分者进行评分,他们对所研究的人群不知情。我们使用线性回归来比较两组在每次就诊时的外貌评分,并评估随时间的变化。回归分析用于检查手术时的年龄与外貌评分之间的关联。
在每次就诊时,患有SSC的儿童的外貌评分均低于未受影响的对照组(所有P<0.001)。外貌评分随时间下降,患有和未患有SSC的儿童的轨迹相似。在病例中,单冠缝和人字缝早闭的儿童评分最低,矢状缝早闭的儿童评分最高。手术时的年龄与外貌评分呈负相关。
患有SSC的儿童的外貌评分低于未受影响的对照组,手术后变化最小。更好的结果与更早的手术相关。这些发现并不表明患有SSC的儿童未能从手术中获益,因为如果不进行手术干预,不对称的头部形状可能会随着时间的推移而恶化。然而,我们的数据表明外貌并未完全“正常化”。