McNickle Gordon G, Deyholos Michael K, Cahill James F
BMC Ecol. 2013 Jul 23;13:28. doi: 10.1186/1472-6785-13-28.
Ecologists recognize that plants capture nitrogen in many chemical forms that include amino acids. Access to multiple nitrogen types in plant communities has been argued to enhance plant performance, access to nitrogen and alter ecological interactions in ways that may promote species coexistence. However, data supporting these arguments have been limited. While it is known that plants uptake amino acids from soil, long term studies that link amino acid uptake to measures of plant performance and potential reproductive effort are not typically performed. Here, a series of experiments that link uptake of nitrate, glutamine or asparagine with lifetime reproductive effort in Arabidopsis thaliana are reported. Nitrogen was offered either singly or in mixture and at a variety of combinations. Traits related to reproductive output were measured, as was the preference for each type of nitrogen.
When plants were supplied with a single nitrogen type at concentrations from 0.1-0.9 mM, the ranking of nitrogen types was nitrate > glutamine > asparagine in terms of the relative performance of plants. When plants were supplied with two types of nitrogen in mixture at ratios between 0.1:0.9-0.9:0.1 mM, again plants performed best when nitrate was present, and poorly when amino acids were mixed. Additionally, stable isotopes revealed that plants preferentially captured nitrogen types matching the hierarchy of nitrate > glutamine > asparagine. Comparing between the two experiments revealed that mixed nitrogen nutrition was a net cost to the plants.
Plant performance on mixed nitrogen was less than half the performance on equal amounts of any single nitrogen type. We asked: why did A. thaliana capture amino acids when doing so resulted in a net cost? We argue that available data cannot yet answer this question, but hypothesize that access to lower quality forms of nitrogen may become important when plants compete.
生态学家认识到植物以多种化学形式捕获氮,其中包括氨基酸。有人认为,植物群落中获取多种氮类型可提高植物性能、获取氮,并以可能促进物种共存的方式改变生态相互作用。然而,支持这些观点的数据有限。虽然已知植物从土壤中吸收氨基酸,但通常不会进行将氨基酸吸收与植物性能指标和潜在繁殖努力联系起来的长期研究。在此,报告了一系列将硝酸盐、谷氨酰胺或天冬酰胺的吸收与拟南芥的终生繁殖努力联系起来的实验。氮以单一或混合形式提供,并采用多种组合。测量了与繁殖输出相关的性状以及对每种氮类型的偏好。
当以0.1 - 0.9 mM的浓度向植物提供单一氮类型时,就植物的相对性能而言,氮类型的排名为硝酸盐>谷氨酰胺>天冬酰胺。当以0.1:0.9 - 0.9:0.1 mM的比例向植物提供两种氮的混合物时,同样,当存在硝酸盐时植物表现最佳,而当氨基酸混合时表现较差。此外,稳定同位素显示植物优先捕获符合硝酸盐>谷氨酰胺>天冬酰胺等级的氮类型。比较这两个实验发现,混合氮营养对植物来说是一种净成本。
植物在混合氮上的表现不到等量任何单一氮类型表现的一半。我们提出疑问:为什么拟南芥在这样做会导致净成本的情况下仍捕获氨基酸?我们认为现有数据尚无法回答这个问题,但推测当植物竞争时,获取质量较低形式的氮可能变得很重要。