Department of Radiation Oncology, Jena University Hospital, Friedrich-Schiller-University Jena, Bachstrasse 18, Jena D-07743, Germany.
Radiat Oncol. 2013 Jul 24;8:187. doi: 10.1186/1748-717X-8-187.
Neurocognitive decline observed after radiotherapy (RT) for brain tumors in long time survivors is attributed to radiation exposure of the hippocampus and the subventricular zone (SVZ). The potential of sparing capabilities for both structures by optimized intensity modulated stereotactic radiotherapy (IMSRT) is investigated.
Brain tumors were irradiated by stereotactic 3D conformal RT or IMSRT using m3 collimator optimized for PTV and for sparing of the conventional OARs (lens, retina, optic nerve, chiasm, cochlea, brain stem and the medulla oblongata). Retrospectively both hippocampi and SVZ were added to the list of OAR and their dose volume histograms were compared to those from two newly generated IMSRT plans using 7 or 14 beamlets (IMSRT-7, IMSRT-14) dedicated for optimized additional sparing of these structures. Conventional OAR constraints were kept constant. Impact of plan complexity and planning target volume (PTV) topography on sparing of both hippocampi and SVZ, conformity index (CI), the homogeneity index (HI) and quality of coverage (QoC) were analyzed. Limits of agreement were used to compare sparing of stem cell niches with either IMSRT-7 or IMSRT-14. The influence of treatment technique related to the topography ratio between PTV and OARs, realized in group A-D, was assessed by a mixed model.
In 47 patients CI (p ≤ 0.003) and HI (p < 0.001) improved by IMSRT-7, IMSRT-14, QoC remained stable (p ≥ 0.50) indicating no compromise in radiotherapy. 90% of normal brain was exposed to a significantly higher dose using IMSRT. IMSRT-7 plans resulted in significantly lower biologically effective doses at all four neural stem cell structures, while contralateral neural stem cells are better spared compared to ipsilateral. A further increase of the number of beamlets (IMSRT-14) did not improve sparing significantly, so IMSRT-7 and IMSRT-14 can be used interchangeable. Patients with tumors contacting neither the subventricular zone nor the cortex benefit most from IMSRT (p < 0.001).
The feasibility of neural stem cell niches sparing with sophisticated linac based inverse IMSRT with 7 beamlets in an unselected cohort of intracranial tumors in relation to topographic situation has been demonstrated. Clinical relevance testing neurotoxicity remains to be demonstrated.
脑肿瘤患者经放疗(RT)治疗后,其认知功能下降可归因于海马体和侧脑室下区(SVZ)的放射暴露。本研究旨在探讨通过优化调强立体定向放疗(IMSRT)是否能改善对这两种结构的保护能力。
采用立体定向 3D 适形 RT 或 m3 准直器优化的 IMSRT 对脑肿瘤进行放疗,m3 准直器优化了适形靶区(PTV)和传统 OARs(晶状体、视网膜、视神经、视交叉、耳蜗、脑干和延髓)的剂量分布。回顾性地将双侧海马体和 SVZ 添加到 OAR 列表中,并将其剂量体积直方图与使用 7 个或 14 个射束(IMSRT-7、IMSRT-14)生成的两个新的 IMSRT 计划进行比较,这些射束专门用于优化这两种结构的额外保护。传统 OAR 限制保持不变。分析计划复杂性和 PTV 拓扑结构对双侧海马体和 SVZ 的保护、适形指数(CI)、均匀性指数(HI)和覆盖率质量(QoC)的影响。采用一致性限比较 IMSRT-7 或 IMSRT-14 对干细胞龛的保护。通过混合模型评估与 PTV 和 OAR 之间的拓扑比相关的治疗技术(分组 A-D)的影响。
在 47 例患者中,CI(p ≤ 0.003)和 HI(p < 0.001)均因 IMSRT-7、IMSRT-14 而改善,QoC 保持稳定(p ≥ 0.50),提示放疗无损伤。90%的正常脑组织受到的照射剂量明显高于 IMSRT。IMSRT-7 计划使所有四个神经干细胞结构的生物有效剂量显著降低,而对侧神经干细胞的保护更好。进一步增加射束数(IMSRT-14)并不能显著改善保护效果,因此 IMSRT-7 和 IMSRT-14 可以互换使用。肿瘤既不接触侧脑室下区也不接触皮质的患者从 IMSRT 中获益最多(p < 0.001)。
在未选择颅内肿瘤患者队列中,已证明使用复杂的基于直线加速器的逆向 IMSRT 并采用 7 个射束对神经干细胞龛进行保护的可行性,与肿瘤的位置有关。尚需进一步研究以评估神经毒性的临床相关性。