Harding Alex, Sweeney Grace
University of Exeter Medical School, UK.
Educ Prim Care. 2013 Jul;24(4):237-43. doi: 10.1080/14739879.2013.11494181.
The opening of a new medical school is a cause for celebration. Starting with a clean slate often gives the opportunity to adopt more modern teaching practices. However, encouraging large numbers of clinicians to start teaching and to adopt these new methods brings its own set of challenges. During the expansion phase of a new medical school, it was often noted that new teachers seemed to have considerable difficulties, and often expressed these as negativity towards student placements. This did not chime with much of the work from established schools, which seemed to evaluate expansion of teaching more positively. We wanted to better understand the issues involved. Semi-structured interviews were conducted involving GPs who had received medical students over the first four years of a newly established medical school. The aims were to assess the impact of the students on the new teachers, and to try to better understand why some teachers were experiencing difficulties. We collected qualitative and quantitative data at the interviews. The qualitative data were analysed using grounded theory which aims to link emerging themes together. The findings suggest that as the quantity of teaching medical students increases, the enjoyment and commitment to teaching may decrease. Concerns over the administration of teaching may begin to predominate. Two factors may help to reduce this: 1 Adequate investment in manpower and premises to reduce time and space constraints on teaching. 2 Practices considering themselves as teaching practices where education is a part of the practice identity.
一所新医学院的开办是值得庆祝的事。白手起家往往能带来采用更现代教学方法的机会。然而,鼓励大量临床医生开始教学并采用这些新方法也带来了一系列自身的挑战。在一所新医学院的扩张阶段,人们经常注意到新教师似乎面临相当大的困难,而且常常将这些困难表现为对学生实习安排的消极态度。这与老牌医学院的许多工作不太相符,老牌医学院似乎对教学扩张的评价更为积极。我们想更好地了解其中涉及的问题。我们对在一所新建医学院头四年接收过医学生的全科医生进行了半结构化访谈。目的是评估学生对新教师的影响,并试图更好地理解为什么一些教师会遇到困难。我们在访谈中收集了定性和定量数据。定性数据采用扎根理论进行分析,该理论旨在将新出现的主题联系起来。研究结果表明,随着医学生教学量的增加,教学的乐趣和投入可能会减少。对教学管理的担忧可能开始占主导地位。有两个因素可能有助于减少这种情况:1. 在人力和场地方面进行充分投资,以减少教学的时间和空间限制。2. 将自己视为教学机构,将教育作为机构身份认同的一部分。