Medical Research Council Biostatistics Unit, Institute of Public Health, Cambridge, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2013 Aug 2;8(8):e69775. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0069775. Print 2013.
The advantages of Bayesian statistical approaches, such as flexibility and the ability to acknowledge uncertainty in all parameters, have made them the prevailing method for analysing the spread of infectious diseases in human or animal populations. We introduce a Bayesian approach to experimental host-pathogen systems that shares these attractive features. Since uncertainty in all parameters is acknowledged, existing information can be accounted for through prior distributions, rather than through fixing some parameter values. The non-linear dynamics, multi-factorial design, multiple measurements of responses over time and sampling error that are typical features of experimental host-pathogen systems can also be naturally incorporated. We analyse the dynamics of the free-living protozoan Paramecium caudatum and its specialist bacterial parasite Holospora undulata. Our analysis provides strong evidence for a saturable infection function, and we were able to reproduce the two waves of infection apparent in the data by separating the initial inoculum from the parasites released after the first cycle of infection. In addition, the parameter estimates from the hierarchical model can be combined to infer variations in the parasite's basic reproductive ratio across experimental groups, enabling us to make predictions about the effect of resources and host genotype on the ability of the parasite to spread. Even though the high level of variability between replicates limited the resolution of the results, this Bayesian framework has strong potential to be used more widely in experimental ecology.
贝叶斯统计方法的优势,如灵活性和承认所有参数不确定性的能力,使它们成为分析人类或动物群体中传染病传播的主要方法。我们引入了一种具有这些吸引人特征的贝叶斯方法来分析实验性宿主-病原体系统。由于承认所有参数的不确定性,因此可以通过先验分布来考虑现有信息,而不是通过固定某些参数值。实验性宿主-病原体系统的典型特征,如非线性动力学、多因素设计、随时间多次测量反应和抽样误差,也可以自然地纳入其中。我们分析了自由生活的原生动物草履虫及其专性细菌寄生虫波动体的动态。我们的分析为饱和感染函数提供了强有力的证据,并且我们通过将初始接种物与第一次感染循环后释放的寄生虫分开,成功地再现了数据中明显的两次感染波。此外,层次模型中的参数估计值可以组合起来推断寄生虫基本繁殖率在实验组之间的变化,使我们能够预测资源和宿主基因型对寄生虫传播能力的影响。尽管重复之间的高度变异性限制了结果的分辨率,但这种贝叶斯框架具有在实验生态学中更广泛应用的强大潜力。