Ho Claudia K, Mabasa Vincent H, Leung Vivian W Y, Malyuk Douglas L, Perrott Jerrold L
, BSc(Pharm), is a Clinical Pharmacy Resident, Lower Mainland Pharmacy Services at Fraser Health, Vancouver, British Columbia.
Can J Hosp Pharm. 2013 Jul;66(4):212-8. doi: 10.4212/cjhp.v66i4.1267.
Clinical pharmacy services have been shown to reduce adverse drug events and health care costs. However, few studies have assessed their effect on patient outcomes in the intensive care unit (ICU).
To describe characteristics of ICU patients with documented pharmacist interventions and to evaluate the relationships between patients' complexity level and pharmacists' interventions and between pharmacists' interventions and mortality rate.
Inpatient records of admissions between January 1, 2004, and March 31, 2007, were analyzed to identify the presence of clinical pharmacy notes (CPNs). The characteristics of patients with and without CPNs were compared using descriptive statistics. For primary analysis of the association between patient complexity level and presence of CPNs, logistic regression modelling was performed to adjust for potential confounding. Logistic regression was also used to explore the possible association between CPNs and mortality. Finally, mortality analysis was carried out for patients with and without CPNs, with matching by complexity level.
The main study cohort comprised 1561 patients: 333 (21.3%) with CPNs and 1228 (78.7%) with no CPNs. A greater proportion of those with a CPN had the highest complexity level: 295 (88.6%) of those with CPNs versus 660 (53.7%) of those with no CPNs. After adjustment for age and sex, the odds ratio for having a CPN among patients with complexity level 4 (relative to patients with lower complexity levels) was 8.20 (95% confidence interval 5.44-12.38). Mortality rates were not significantly different between the 2 groups: 26.7% (89/333) among patients with CPNs and 27.9% (343/1228) among those without CPNs (p = 0.66). After adjustment for age, sex, complexity level, and length of stay in the ICU, the presence of a CPN was not significantly associated with mortality. Mortality rates in the matched cohort (n = 1078) were also similar between patients with and without CPNs (89/333 [26.7%] and 226/745 [30.3%], respectively; p = 0.23), and the presence of a CPN was not significantly associated with mortality after adjustments for potential confounding factors.
Documenting clinical pharmacy activities is essential for assessing pharmacists' impact on patient outcomes. These data suggest that ICU pharmacists prioritize clinical activities to care for the sickest patients.
临床药学服务已被证明可减少药物不良事件和医疗保健成本。然而,很少有研究评估其对重症监护病房(ICU)患者结局的影响。
描述有药师干预记录的ICU患者的特征,并评估患者复杂程度与药师干预之间以及药师干预与死亡率之间的关系。
分析2004年1月1日至2007年3月31日期间住院患者的记录,以确定临床药学记录(CPN)的存在情况。使用描述性统计比较有和没有CPN的患者的特征。为了对患者复杂程度与CPN存在之间的关联进行初步分析,进行逻辑回归建模以调整潜在的混杂因素。逻辑回归也用于探索CPN与死亡率之间的可能关联。最后,对有和没有CPN的患者进行死亡率分析,并按复杂程度进行匹配。
主要研究队列包括1561例患者:333例(21.3%)有CPN,1228例(78.7%)没有CPN。有CPN的患者中,处于最高复杂程度的比例更高:有CPN的患者中295例(88.6%),没有CPN的患者中660例(53.7%)。在调整年龄和性别后,复杂程度为4级的患者(相对于复杂程度较低的患者)有CPN的比值比为8.20(95%置信区间5.44 - 12.38)。两组的死亡率没有显著差异:有CPN的患者中为26.7%(89/333),没有CPN的患者中为27.9%(343/1228)(p = 0.66)。在调整年龄、性别、复杂程度和ICU住院时间后,CPN的存在与死亡率没有显著关联。匹配队列(n = 1078)中有和没有CPN的患者的死亡率也相似(分别为89/333 [26.7%]和226/745 [30.3%];p = 0.23),在调整潜在混杂因素后,CPN的存在与死亡率没有显著关联。
记录临床药学活动对于评估药师对患者结局的影响至关重要。这些数据表明,ICU药师将临床活动的重点放在照顾病情最严重的患者上。