Hemasathya Bahavathi Ananthan, Balagopal Sundaresan
Department of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics, Tagore Dental College and Hospital, The Tamilnadu Dr. M.G.R. Medical University, Chennai, India.
J Forensic Dent Sci. 2013 Jan;5(1):35-41. doi: 10.4103/0975-1475.114561.
Comparing ante-mortem and post-mortem dental data is a principal method of identification in forensic odontology. Radiographic images of amalgam have been used in dental forensics for identification due to their unique appearance.
The aim of this study was to investigate whether radio-opaque composite restorations have a potential for identification in forensic odontology.
Thirty typodont mandibular first molar teeth were prepared with Class-II (proximo-occlusal) cavities and restored with a radio-opaque composite (Tetric N-Ceram). Two sets of standardized radiographs were taken from the 30 teeth, keeping the radiological parameters constant. One set of these 30 radiographs was named as SET 1. Ten randomly chosen radiographs from the other set and two other radiographs of Class-II composite restorations in typodont teeth constituted SET 2. Thirty dentally trained examiners were asked to match the 12 radiographic images of SET 2 with those of SET 1.
The results show that 15 examiners were able to correctly match all the 12 images. Statistical analysis was done using kappa statistical test.
This study shows that, if the post-mortem radiographs are accurate duplicates of ante-mortem radiographs of composite restorations, then the shape of the composite restoration is unique and can be used for identification.
比较生前和死后的牙齿数据是法医牙科学中身份鉴定的主要方法。由于汞合金独特的外观,其放射图像已被用于牙科法医鉴定。
本研究的目的是调查不透射线的复合树脂修复体在法医牙科学中是否具有身份鉴定的潜力。
选取30颗典型下颌第一磨牙制备II类(近中-咬合面)洞型,并用不透射线的复合树脂(Tetric N-Ceram)进行修复。从这30颗牙齿上拍摄两组标准化的X光片,保持放射参数不变。这30张X光片中的一组被命名为第1组。从另一组中随机选取10张X光片以及典型牙齿中II类复合树脂修复体的另外两张X光片构成第2组。30名经过牙科培训的检查人员被要求将第2组的12张X光图像与第1组的进行匹配。
结果显示,15名检查人员能够正确匹配所有12张图像。使用kappa统计检验进行统计分析。
本研究表明,如果死后X光片是复合树脂修复体生前X光片的精确复制品,那么复合树脂修复体的形状是独特的,可用于身份鉴定。