Pretty Iain A, Smith Philip W, Edgar W Michael, Higham Susan M
Dept of Clinical Dental Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, The University of Liverpool, England.
J Forensic Sci. 2002 Jul;47(4):831-6.
There has been a large increase in the number of tooth colored restorations "white fillings" placed in recent years. An increased demand from the public for more aesthetic dental restorations causes a potential problem for forensic dentists who may find the fillings difficult to identify and hence include in postmortem odontograms. This has implications for the accuracy of dental identifications, particularly in situations where limited time is available for postmortem identification, e.g., mass casualty incidents. A new method for the detection of composite restorations is presented. Quantitative Light-induced Fluorescence (QLF) is a technique currently employed to detect small changes in enamel mineral content. An experiment was conducted to determine if the technique would afford a greater degree of contrast between composite and enamel and thus enable the accuracy of composite identification in enamel. Twenty-four previously extracted human premolars were gently cleaned with pumice and wet-and-dry paper. Twelve were subsequently randomly selected and restored on their buccal surfaces with Spectrum (a composite) following manufacturer's instructions. No attempt was made to color match the teeth and all were filled with shade B3. Twelve teeth were left unrestored. QLF and normal white light images were taken of both restored and non-restored surfaces with teeth wet and then dried. Ten forensic dentists were asked on two separate occasions (one month between each attempt) to indicate whether or not they thought the surface was: a) restored or b) unrestored. Results indicate that forensic dentists detected a significantly higher proportion (p<0.005) of filled surfaces with QLF.
近年来,牙齿颜色修复体(“白色填充物”)的数量大幅增加。公众对更美观的牙齿修复体需求增加,这给法医牙医带来了一个潜在问题,他们可能会发现这些填充物难以识别,因此难以纳入死后牙片。这对牙齿鉴定的准确性有影响,特别是在死后鉴定时间有限的情况下,例如大规模伤亡事件。本文介绍了一种检测复合树脂修复体的新方法。定量光诱导荧光(QLF)是一种目前用于检测牙釉质矿物质含量微小变化的技术。进行了一项实验,以确定该技术是否能在复合树脂和牙釉质之间提供更大程度的对比度,从而提高在牙釉质中识别复合树脂的准确性。24颗先前拔除的人类前磨牙先用浮石以及干湿纸轻轻清洁。随后随机选择12颗,按照制造商的说明在其颊面用Spectrum(一种复合树脂)进行修复。未尝试使牙齿颜色匹配,所有牙齿均填充B3色。12颗牙齿未进行修复。在牙齿湿润然后干燥的情况下,对修复和未修复的表面都拍摄了QLF图像和普通白光图像。十位法医牙医被要求在两个不同的场合(每次尝试间隔一个月)指出他们是否认为该表面:a)已修复或b)未修复。结果表明,法医牙医通过QLF检测到的填充表面比例显著更高(p<0.005)。