Asan Onur, Ye Zhan, Acharya Amit
Industrial and Systems Engineering, University of Wisconsin-Madison, WI, USA.
J Am Dent Assoc. 2013 Sep;144(9):1022-9. doi: 10.14219/jada.archive.2013.0229.
The use of electronic health records (EHRs) in dental care and their effect on dental care provider-patient interaction have not been studied sufficiently. The authors conducted a study to explore dental care providers' interactions with EHRs during patient visits, how these interactions influence dental care provider-patient communication, and the providers' and patients' perception of EHR use in the dental clinic setting during patient visits.
The authors collected survey and interview data from patients and providers at three dental clinics in a health care system. The authors used qualitative and quantitative methods to analyze data obtained from patients and dental care providers.
The provider survey results showed significant differences in perceptions of EHR use in patient visits across dental care provider groups (dentists, dental hygienists and dental assistants). Patient survey results indicated that some patients experienced a certain level of frustration and distraction because of providers' use of EHRs during the visit.
The provider survey results indicated that there are different perceptions across provider groups about EHRs and the effect of computer use on communication with patients. Dental assistants generally reported more negative effects on communication with patients owing to computer use. Interview results also indicated that dental care providers may not feel comfortable interacting with the EHR without having any verbal or eye contact with patients during the patient's dental visit.
A new design for dental operatories and locations of computer screens within the operatories should be undertaken to prevent negative nonverbal communication such as loss of eye contact or forcing the provider and patient to sit back to back, as well as to enhance patient education and information sharing.
电子健康记录(EHRs)在牙科护理中的应用及其对牙科护理提供者与患者互动的影响尚未得到充分研究。作者开展了一项研究,以探讨牙科护理提供者在患者就诊期间与电子健康记录的互动情况、这些互动如何影响牙科护理提供者与患者的沟通,以及提供者和患者对在牙科诊所就诊期间使用电子健康记录的看法。
作者收集了来自医疗保健系统中三家牙科诊所的患者和提供者的调查及访谈数据。作者使用定性和定量方法分析从患者和牙科护理提供者处获得的数据。
提供者调查结果显示,不同牙科护理提供者群体(牙医、牙科保健员和牙科助理)对患者就诊时使用电子健康记录的看法存在显著差异。患者调查结果表明,一些患者因提供者在就诊期间使用电子健康记录而感到一定程度的沮丧和分心。
提供者调查结果表明,不同提供者群体对电子健康记录以及使用计算机对与患者沟通的影响存在不同看法。牙科助理普遍报告称,使用计算机对与患者的沟通有更多负面影响。访谈结果还表明,牙科护理提供者在患者看牙期间与电子健康记录互动时,如果没有与患者进行任何言语或眼神交流,可能会感到不自在。
应重新设计牙科诊疗室以及诊疗室内计算机屏幕的位置,以防止出现眼神交流缺失或迫使提供者和患者背靠背等负面非言语沟通情况,同时加强患者教育和信息共享。