McClenaghan F, Fell M, Martin D, Smith G, McGurk M
The Royal London Hospital, London, UK.
Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2013 Dec;42(12):1587-91. doi: 10.1016/j.ijom.2013.07.748. Epub 2013 Sep 7.
Surgical missions to the developing world have been criticized for their lack of outcome analysis. Reported studies indicate a high rate of postoperative complications. An integrated pathway developed for surgical missions and a report of its performance in action is presented herein. Patients were optimized for surgery by a medical team from the UK for a minimum of 14 days preoperatively. They were then transferred to hospital for surgery and returned when stable. At the completion of the mission a junior doctor remained behind for 3 weeks to chart the patients' progress. Thirty case patients were treated over a 2-week period. The complication rate at 3 weeks postoperatively was 7/30. Twenty-two operations were classified as complex (over 1h with more than one flap) and eight as simple (under 1h with minimal flaps). Of those undergoing the simple operations, 2/8 encountered complications at an average of 5 days postoperatively (range 3-7 days). Many medical teams depart in an elevated atmosphere of accomplishment, which without an outcome analysis gives a false impression of their positive impact. Outcome analysis is essential to honestly appraise the effect of surgical missions.
前往发展中世界的外科手术任务因缺乏结果分析而受到批评。报告的研究表明术后并发症发生率很高。本文介绍了为外科手术任务开发的综合路径及其实际执行情况报告。患者在术前由来自英国的医疗团队进行至少14天的手术优化。然后他们被转移到医院进行手术,病情稳定后返回。任务结束时,一名初级医生留下来3周以记录患者的进展情况。在两周的时间里治疗了30例患者。术后3周的并发症发生率为7/30。22例手术被归类为复杂手术(超过1小时且有多个皮瓣),8例为简单手术(不到1小时且皮瓣最少)。在接受简单手术的患者中,2/8在术后平均5天(范围3 - 7天)出现并发症。许多医疗团队在一种成就感高涨的氛围中离开,而没有结果分析会给人一种其产生积极影响的错误印象。结果分析对于诚实地评估外科手术任务的效果至关重要。