Department of Psychology, Emory University, 36 Eagle Row, Atlanta, GA 30322, USA.
Curr Biol. 2013 Sep 9;23(17):R801-6. doi: 10.1016/j.cub.2013.07.016.
Episodic memories differ from other types of memory because they represent aspects of the past not present in other memories, such as the time, place, or social context in which the memories were formed. Focus on phenomenal experience in human memory, such as the sense of 'having been there', has resulted in conceptualizations of episodic memory that are difficult or impossible to apply to nonhuman species. It is therefore a significant challenge for investigators to agree on objective behavioral criteria that can be applied in nonhuman animals and still capture features of memory thought to be critical in humans. Some investigators have attempted to use neurobiological parallels to bridge this gap; however, defining memory types on the basis of the brain structures involved rather than on identified cognitive mechanisms risks missing crucial functional aspects of episodic memory, which are ultimately behavioral. The most productive way forward is likely a combination of neurobiology and sophisticated cognitive testing that identifies the mental representations present in episodic memory. Investigators that have refined their approach from asking the naïve question "do nonhuman animals have episodic memory" to instead asking "what aspects of episodic memory are shared by humans and nonhumans" are making progress.
情景记忆不同于其他类型的记忆,因为它们代表了过去的某些方面,而这些方面在其他记忆中并不存在,例如形成记忆时的时间、地点或社会背景。关注人类记忆中的现象体验,例如“曾经在那里”的感觉,导致了情景记忆的概念化,这些概念化对于非人类物种来说是难以或不可能应用的。因此,研究人员面临着一个重大挑战,即需要就可以应用于非人类动物的客观行为标准达成一致意见,同时仍然能够捕捉到被认为对人类至关重要的记忆特征。一些研究人员试图利用神经生物学的相似性来弥合这一差距;然而,基于涉及的大脑结构而不是已识别的认知机制来定义记忆类型,可能会忽略情景记忆的关键功能方面,而这些功能方面最终是行为方面的。最有成效的方法可能是将神经生物学和复杂的认知测试相结合,以确定情景记忆中存在的心理表象。那些从提出天真的问题“非人类动物是否具有情景记忆”转变为“人类和非人类动物共享情景记忆的哪些方面”的研究人员正在取得进展。