Torres M A, Furst D E
University of Medicine and Dentistry, New Jersey, Robert Wood Johnson Medical School, New Brunswick.
Rheum Dis Clin North Am. 1990 Feb;16(1):217-41.
Over the years, many encouraging uncontrolled studies extolling treatments of SSc have appeared, but initial impressions were not corroborated when controlled trials were done. This article points out that certain recent studies have effectively ruled out the use of some specific therapies for the general treatment of systemic sclerosis. Thus, sufficient data has been generated to rule out the use of n-acetylcysteine, colchicine, chlorambucil, cyclofenil, and DMSO, at least in disease of longer duration. Ketanserin and prostaglandin infusions probably also belong in this group, as they affect only Raynaud's phenomenon. Angiotensin enzyme inhibitors, while probably life-saving in renal crises, do not seem to affect the underlying systemic sclerosis per se. Another group of drugs has only limited supportive data and await well-controlled trials to prove or disprove their effectiveness. These include: 5-fluorouracil, D-penicillamine, drugs affecting platelet function (dipyridamole), and para-aminobenzoic acid. There are a few treatments which have potential. Factor XIII has only limited data using controlled trials, but what does exist seems positive. Apheresis is encouraging, although the success of this treatment modality may be dependent upon a "combination" approach. Ongoing studies with gamma-interferon, photopheresis, and the mast cell stabilizer ketotifen appear exciting, and we await reports of their use in scleroderma. On another level, new insights into genomic alterations in skin fibroblasts and T-cell proto-oncogene expression have contributed to the understanding of the pathogenesis of this disease at the cellular level and new methods to measure change in disease will help gauge response to therapy. Thus, we look forward to more definitive treatment of SSc in the future.
多年来,出现了许多令人鼓舞的关于硬皮病治疗的非对照研究,但进行对照试验时,最初的印象并未得到证实。本文指出,近期的某些研究已有效地排除了某些特定疗法用于系统性硬化症的常规治疗。因此,已产生了足够的数据来排除使用N-乙酰半胱氨酸、秋水仙碱、苯丁酸氮芥、环芬尼和二甲基亚砜,至少对于病程较长的疾病是如此。酮色林和前列腺素输注可能也属于这一类,因为它们仅影响雷诺现象。血管紧张素酶抑制剂虽然在肾危象中可能挽救生命,但似乎本身并不影响潜在的系统性硬化症。另一组药物仅有有限的支持性数据,有待进行严格对照试验以证明或反驳其有效性。这些药物包括:5-氟尿嘧啶、D-青霉胺、影响血小板功能的药物(双嘧达莫)和对氨基苯甲酸。有几种治疗方法具有潜力。因子 XIII 在对照试验中的数据有限,但已有的数据似乎是积极的。血液分离术令人鼓舞,尽管这种治疗方式的成功可能取决于“联合”方法。正在进行的关于γ-干扰素、光分离置换法和肥大细胞稳定剂酮替芬的研究似乎令人兴奋,我们期待有关它们在硬皮病中应用的报告。在另一个层面上,对皮肤成纤维细胞基因组改变和 T 细胞原癌基因表达的新见解有助于在细胞水平上理解这种疾病的发病机制,而测量疾病变化的新方法将有助于评估对治疗的反应。因此,我们期待未来对硬皮病有更确切的治疗方法。