Clinical, Health and Neuropsychology, Leiden University, Wassenaarseweg 52, Leiden, the Netherlands.
BMC Fam Pract. 2013 Sep 26;14:142. doi: 10.1186/1471-2296-14-142.
The introduction of efficacious physical activity interventions in primary health care is a complex process. Understanding factors influencing the process can enhance the development of effective introduction strategies. This Delphi study aimed to identify factors most relevant for the adoption, implementation, and continuation of physical activity interventions in primary health care by examining experts' opinions on the importance and changeability of factors previously identified as potentially relevant for the process.
In the first round, 44 experts scored factors on their importance for each stage of the introduction process, as well as on their changeability. In the second round, the same experts received a questionnaire containing a reduced list of factors, based on the first-round results. They were asked to indicate their top-10 most important factors for each stage, and to re-rate factors' changeability. Thirty-seven experts completed this round.
Most important factors could be identified for each stage. Some factors were found important for a specific stage, e.g., the presence of intervention champions within the organization (adoption), provider knowledge (implementation), and the intervention's sustainability (continuation), while others were perceived important for all stages, i.e., the intervention's financial feasibility, the intervention's accessibility to the target group, and time to deliver the intervention. The majority of most important factors was perceived changeable. However, for some factors no consensus could be reached regarding their changeability.
This study identified general and stage-specific factors relevant for the introduction of physical activity interventions in primary health care. It emphasizes the importance of taking these factors into account when designing introduction strategies, and of giving special attention to the distinct stages of the process. Due to lack of consensus on the changeability of most important factors, the extent to which these factors can be influenced by introduction strategies remains unclear.
在初级医疗保健中引入有效的体育活动干预是一个复杂的过程。了解影响这一过程的因素可以增强制定有效引入策略的能力。本德尔菲研究旨在通过检查专家对以前被认为对该过程具有潜在相关性的因素的重要性和可变性的意见,确定在初级医疗保健中采用、实施和延续体育活动干预的最相关因素。
在第一轮中,44 名专家根据各阶段对因素进行了重要性评分,以及对因素的可变性评分。在第二轮中,同一批专家收到了一份根据第一轮结果编制的、因素数量有所减少的问卷。他们被要求为每个阶段列出最重要的前 10 个因素,并重新评估因素的可变性。37 名专家完成了这一轮。
可以为每个阶段确定最重要的因素。一些因素被认为对特定阶段很重要,例如组织内的干预冠军(采用)、提供者知识(实施)和干预的可持续性(延续),而另一些因素则被认为对所有阶段都很重要,即干预的财务可行性、干预对目标群体的可及性以及提供干预的时间。大多数最重要的因素被认为是可改变的。然而,对于一些因素,其可变性没有达成共识。
本研究确定了在初级医疗保健中引入体育活动干预的一般因素和阶段特异性因素。它强调在设计引入策略时考虑这些因素的重要性,并特别关注该过程的不同阶段。由于对最重要因素的可变性缺乏共识,因此尚不清楚这些因素在多大程度上可以受到引入策略的影响。