Dr. Cherniak is a family medicine resident, Scarborough Hospital, University of Toronto, Faculty of Medicine, Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Dr. Drain is instructor of medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital and Brigham and Women's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts. Dr. Brewer is professor of medicine, David Geffen School of Medicine, Department of Medicine, University of California, Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California.
Acad Med. 2013 Nov;88(11):1778-81. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0b013e3182a6a7ce.
Although most medical schools and residency programs offer international medical electives (IMEs), little guidance on the educational objectives for these rotations exists; thus, the authors reviewed the literature to compile and categorize a comprehensive set of educational objectives for IMEs.
In February and July 2012, the authors searched SciVerse Scopus online, which includes the Embase and MEDLINE databases, using specified terms. From the articles that met their inclusion criteria, they extracted the educational objectives of IMEs and sorted them into preelective, intraelective, and postelective objectives.
The authors identified and reviewed 255 articles, 11 (4%) of which described 22 educational objectives. Among those 22 objectives, 5 (23%), 15 (68%), and 2 (9%) were, respectively, preelective, intraelective, and postelective objectives. Among preelective objectives, only cultural awareness appeared in more than 2 articles (3/11; 27%). Among intraelective objectives, the most commonly defined were enhancing clinical skills and understanding different health care systems (9/11; 82%). Learning to manage diseases rarely seen at home and increasing cultural awareness appeared in nearly half (5/11; 45%) of all articles. Among postelective objectives, reflecting on experiences through a written project was most common (9/11; 82%).
The authors identified 22 educational objectives for IMEs in the published literature, some of which were consistent across institutions. These consistencies, in conjunction with future research, can be used as a framework on which institutions can build their own IME curricula, ultimately helping to ensure that their medical trainees have a meaningful learning experience while abroad.
尽管大多数医学院校和住院医师培训项目都提供国际医学实习(IME),但针对这些轮转的教育目标却缺乏指导;因此,作者查阅文献,对 IME 的教育目标进行了总结和分类。
2012 年 2 月和 7 月,作者使用特定术语在 SciVerse Scopus 在线数据库中搜索,该数据库包括 Embase 和 MEDLINE 数据库。从符合纳入标准的文章中,作者提取了 IME 的教育目标,并将其分为预选、实习中和实习后目标。
作者共确定并回顾了 255 篇文章,其中 11 篇(4%)描述了 22 个教育目标。在这 22 个目标中,分别有 5 个(23%)、15 个(68%)和 2 个(9%)是预选、实习中和实习后目标。在预选目标中,只有文化意识在超过 2 篇文章中出现(3/11;27%)。在实习中目标中,最常被定义的是提高临床技能和了解不同的医疗体系(9/11;82%)。学习管理在国内很少见的疾病和提高文化意识在近一半(5/11;45%)的文章中出现。在实习后目标中,通过书面项目反思经验最为常见(9/11;82%)。
作者在已发表文献中确定了 22 个 IME 的教育目标,其中一些在不同机构中是一致的。这些一致性,结合未来的研究,可以作为机构建立自己的 IME 课程的框架,最终有助于确保他们的医学生在国外有一个有意义的学习体验。