Dobb B, Cooper J
B Dobb, Acute Medicine Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, Foresterhill, Aberdeen AB25 2ZN, UK.
J R Coll Physicians Edinb. 2013;43(3):207-14. doi: 10.4997/JRCPE.2013.304.
Traditionally, neurologically pristine patients with a thunderclap headache are investigated with a non-contrast computed tomography (CT) brain scan, which if negative is followed by a lumbar puncture (LP) to exclude important secondary causes, particularly subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH). However, misdiagnosis of such patients is still a cause of significant human and financial cost and a regular reason for medical litigation. This study explores the approach of emergency medicine and acute medicine clinicians to the investigation of a patient with thunderclap headache.
Clinicians were invited to complete an online survey based on a clinical vignette of a 45-year-old man presenting with a thunderclap headache who had a pristine neurological examination.
A total of 160 clinicians responded. The majority (89%) elected to perform a non-contrast CT brain as their first investigation, though five clinicians discharged the patient without investigation. If the CT was negative, only 84% would then proceed to LP, but 20% would undertake this investigation before 12 hours from headache onset.
Most clinicians investigate neurologically intact patients with thunderclap headache following a CT/LP strategy, but deviations from recommended practice are common.
传统上,对于突发霹雳样头痛且神经系统检查无异常的患者,首先会进行脑部非增强计算机断层扫描(CT),若结果为阴性,则接着进行腰椎穿刺(LP)以排除重要的继发性病因,尤其是蛛网膜下腔出血(SAH)。然而,这类患者的误诊仍然会造成巨大的人力和财力损失,也是引发医疗纠纷的常见原因。本研究探讨了急诊医学和急性医学临床医生对突发霹雳样头痛患者的检查方法。
邀请临床医生根据一名45岁突发霹雳样头痛且神经系统检查无异常的男性患者的临床病例完成一项在线调查。
共有160名临床医生做出回应。大多数(89%)选择将脑部非增强CT作为首选检查,不过有5名临床医生未进行检查就将患者放走。如果CT结果为阴性,只有84%的医生会接着进行LP,但有20%的医生会在头痛发作12小时内进行该项检查。
大多数临床医生按照CT/LP策略对突发霹雳样头痛且神经系统正常的患者进行检查,但偏离推荐做法的情况很常见。