MSk Lab, Imperial College, London, England.
J Arthroplasty. 2013 Oct;28(9 Suppl):176-8. doi: 10.1016/j.arth.2013.07.036.
Top walking speed (TWS) was used to compare UKA with TKA. Two groups of 23 patients, well matched for age, gender, height and weight and radiological severity were recruited based on high functional scores, more than twelve months post UKA or TKA. These were compared with 14 preop patients and 14 normal controls. Their gait was measured at increasing speeds on a treadmill instrumented with force plates. Both arthroplasty groups were significantly faster than the preop OA group. TKA patients walked substantially faster than any previously reported series of knee arthroplasties. UKA patients walked 10% faster than TKA, although not as fast as the normal controls. Stride length was 5% greater and stance time 7% shorter following UKA - both much closer to normal than TKA. Unlike TKA, UKA enables a near normal gait one year after surgery.
采用最大步行速度(TWS)比较 UKA 与 TKA。根据高功能评分,招募了两组年龄、性别、身高和体重以及影像学严重程度相匹配的 23 例患者,分别接受 UKA 或 TKA 术后 12 个月以上。这些患者与 14 例术前 OA 患者和 14 例正常对照组进行了比较。他们在带有测力板的跑步机上以递增速度进行步态测量。两个关节置换组的步行速度均明显快于术前 OA 组。TKA 患者的步行速度明显快于之前报道的任何一系列膝关节置换术患者。UKA 患者的步行速度比 TKA 快 10%,尽管不如正常对照组快。UKA 后步长增加 5%,站立时间缩短 7%——两者均比 TKA 更接近正常。与 TKA 不同,UKA 术后一年可实现接近正常的步态。