Thalheim L, Williams L E, Borst L B, Fogle J E, Suter S E
Department of Clinical Sciences, College of Veterinary Medicine, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC.
J Vet Intern Med. 2013 Nov-Dec;27(6):1509-16. doi: 10.1111/jvim.12185. Epub 2013 Sep 20.
Immunohistochemistry (IHC), flow cytometry (FC), and PCR for antigen receptor rearrangements (PARR) are 3 widely utilized tests to determine immunophenotype in dogs with lymphoma (LSA).
This study evaluated the ability of FC and PARR to correctly predict immunophenotype as defined by IHC and to determine the level of agreement among the 3 tests.
Sixty-two dogs with lymphoma.
Retrospective study. Medical records were searched to identify dogs with LSA that had concurrent IHC, FC, and PARR performed. Immunophenotype results were categorized as B-cell, T-cell, dual immunophenotype (B- and T-cell), or indeterminate. The results of FC and PARR were evaluated for correctly classifying B- and T-cell LSA as compared with IHC. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV) were evaluated in addition to concordance between each test.
The sensitivity of FC was significantly higher than PARR for both B-cell (91% versus 67%; P < 0.0072) and T-cell (100% versus 75%; P < 0.0312) LSA. The percent agreement between FC and IHC was 94%, between PARR and IHC was 69%, between FC and PARR was 63%, and among all 3 tests was 63%.
Flow cytometry is superior to PARR in correctly predicting immunophenotype when evaluating lymph nodes from dogs already diagnosed with B- or T-cell LSA. If fresh samples are not available for FC, PARR is an acceptable assay for determination of immunophenotype given its high specificity.
免疫组织化学(IHC)、流式细胞术(FC)以及抗原受体重排聚合酶链反应(PARR)是用于确定淋巴瘤犬免疫表型的3种广泛应用的检测方法。
本研究评估FC和PARR正确预测由IHC定义的免疫表型的能力,并确定这3种检测方法之间的一致性水平。
62只淋巴瘤犬。
回顾性研究。检索病历以确定同时进行了IHC、FC和PARR检测的淋巴瘤犬。免疫表型结果分为B细胞型、T细胞型、双免疫表型(B细胞和T细胞)或不确定型。将FC和PARR的结果与IHC进行比较,评估其对B细胞型和T细胞型淋巴瘤的正确分类能力。除了评估每种检测方法之间的一致性外,还评估了敏感性、特异性、阳性预测值(PPV)和阴性预测值(NPV)。
对于B细胞型淋巴瘤(91%对67%;P < 0.0072)和T细胞型淋巴瘤(100%对75%;P < 0.0312),FC的敏感性均显著高于PARR。FC与IHC之间的一致性百分比为94%,PARR与IHC之间为69%,FC与PARR之间为63%,所有3种检测方法之间为63%。
在评估已确诊为B细胞型或T细胞型淋巴瘤犬的淋巴结时,流式细胞术在正确预测免疫表型方面优于PARR。如果没有新鲜样本用于FC检测,鉴于PARR具有较高的特异性,它是一种可接受的免疫表型检测方法。