Kohnstamm Institute, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Dyslexia. 2013 Nov;19(4):256-80. doi: 10.1002/dys.1465.
Children with low (pre-)literacy skills may benefit from individual tutoring during the early phases of learning to read. Dutch at-risk students from 13 schools received in first and second grade a computerized reading intervention, delivered by non-professional tutors at school. Digital logs indicated that treatment integrity was lower than intended; therefore, the intervention group was subdivided using a completion criterion. Third grade assessments revealed that the subgroup that had finished the program successfully (IF, N = 40) was able to read as fluent as the average reader, outperforming the subgroup that had not completely finished the program (InF, N = 31) as well as the group that had not worked with the program (controls, N = 66) on all reading measures. This study demonstrates that a well-implemented tutoring model can serve as a (cost-)effective complement to the classroom practice for beginning readers.
阅读能力较低(或有阅读困难)的儿童可能受益于在早期学习阅读阶段接受个别辅导。来自 13 所学校的荷兰有风险的学生在一年级和二年级接受了由非专业教师在学校提供的计算机阅读干预。数字日志显示,治疗的完整性低于预期;因此,使用完成标准对干预组进行了细分。三年级的评估结果表明,成功完成该计划的子组(IF,N=40)的阅读流利程度与平均阅读者一样,优于未完全完成该计划的子组(InF,N=31)以及未使用该计划的子组(对照组,N=66),在所有阅读测试上都表现出色。本研究表明,实施良好的辅导模式可以成为(成本效益高的)补充手段,为初学者提供课堂阅读实践。